Second-Trimester D&E With Financial, Legal, and Postoperative Constraints
34-year-old G4P2 at 17 weeks 4 days by ultrasound presents for abortion. She has had two low transverse cesarean births and has a BMI of 42 and hemoglobin 10.2 g/dL. She has PTSD after a prior sexual assault and asks for trauma-informed care. She lives in a state with a 12-week abortion ban and has traveled to your clinic; her Medicaid will not pay for out-of-state care, the clinic fee is $2,400, and she has $1,500 and childcare for two days. She is Rh-negative and has no known allergies. She wants an outpatient D&E and asks whether she can have it done in one day.
1. Outline the preoperative assessment and procedural plan, including cervical preparation and anesthesia considerations.
Read the worked answer
Preoperative assessment should confirm gestational age by ultrasound, document Rh status, obtain CBC and type and screen, and review anesthesia risk with BMI 42. Ultrasound should also locate the placenta; with two prior cesareans, a low-lying anterior placenta raises concern for placenta accreta spectrum and may require referral rather than office D&E. At 17–18 weeks, cervical preparation with osmotic dilators placed the day before, often with adjunct misoprostol, is standard; same-day D&E is possible at some centers but is less predictable at this gestational age and with a nulliparous cervix or prior cesareans. Trauma-informed care includes explaining each step, offering a support person, minimizing unnecessary examinations, and allowing her to control positioning and breaks.
Intraoperatively, use ultrasound guidance, adequate anesthesia, and uterotonics; have hemorrhage precautions available. Prior low transverse cesareans do not contraindicate D&E, but uterine perforation and hemorrhage risks are higher, and the surgeon should be experienced. Anemia should be optimized if time permits; cross-matched blood may not be necessary at this hemoglobin but should be available for heavy bleeding. Discharge planning must include bleeding precautions and a reliable contact.
2. How do you address the financial, legal, and logistical barriers without compromising care or confidentiality?
Read the worked answer
Barriers should be treated as part of the clinical problem, not as reasons for delay. Confirm that the procedure is lawful in your state and that any waiting period or reporting requirement is satisfied. Connect her with abortion funds and practical-support organizations for the $900 shortfall, lodging, and transportation; involve a social worker early. Do not submit claims to a Medicaid plan that will not cover the service without explaining the risk of an explanation of benefits; offer self-pay and confidentiality-preserving billing. If she has only two days of childcare, prioritize a schedule that fits, but do not compromise cervical preparation or safety.
Ethically, nonabandonment and justice require that financial barriers not determine whether she receives evidence-based care. Document the barriers and the referrals made. Avoid sharing information with anyone she has not authorized. If she cannot complete a two-day procedure, discuss referral to a center that can provide same-day care or an induction protocol, with explicit risks and alternatives.
3. She undergoes an uncomplicated D&E and returns on postoperative day 5 with fever 38.7°C, pelvic pain, and foul lochia. Ultrasound shows a 2-cm echogenic mass in the lower uterus. What is your management?
Read the worked answer
This presentation suggests postabortion endometritis with retained tissue until proven otherwise. Obtain vital signs, blood and urine cultures, and a CBC, and begin broad-spectrum intravenous antibiotics covering anaerobes and gram-negative organisms. Because she is febrile and has a retained echogenic mass, oral antibiotics alone are inadequate. Admit for intravenous therapy and perform uterine evacuation after stabilization; ultrasound guidance reduces the risk of perforation, especially given her prior cesareans. Send tissue for pathology and, if infection is severe, consider cultures.
Also evaluate for uterine perforation, pelvic abscess, and hemorrhage. If she is hemodynamically unstable or has peritoneal signs, obtain cross-sectional imaging and involve surgery. Once afebrile and tolerating oral intake, transition to oral antibiotics. Counsel her that retained tissue can occur even after a technically successful procedure and that fever, worsening pain, or heavy bleeding requires urgent return.