The Patient Who Says She Hates Exercise
Maria, 47, was referred after a routine visit found an A1c of 6.2% and a BMI of 34. She works two jobs and cares for two children. She has tried "every diet" and lost weight several times, only to regain it. She says, "I know I should exercise, but I don't have time, and gyms are for fit people. Besides, my knees hurt when I walk too much." She has not exercised in over a year. She agreed to meet with you but has not committed to a program. She is not currently depressed and denies chest pain or other symptoms.
1. Identify her stage of change and the evidence for your judgment.
Read the worked answer
She is in contemplation, not preparation or action.
Evidence: she acknowledges the problem ("I know I should") but has not taken any recent action, has no plan, and volunteers barriers rather than solutions. Her history of dieting attempts shows she is not unmotivated; she has simply experienced repeated failure with approaches that did not fit her life.
Why this matters: giving her a full exercise prescription now would be a mismatch. In contemplation, the work is to tip the decisional balance and build confidence, not to hand over a schedule. The goal of this visit is one believable next step she chooses herself, with a plan to revisit.
2. Write three motivational-interviewing-consistent responses to her statement, and explain why each works.
Read the worked answer
Complex reflection: "You've put real effort into this before, and it's frustrating to end up back where you started - and you're not sure exercise is going to be any different." This names the frustration and the discouragement without arguing, and shows you heard the history rather than the excuse.
Double-sided reflection: "On one hand, you're exhausted by two jobs and sore knees; on the other, you're here because the A1c result worried you." This holds both sides and lets her voice the change side rather than you doing it.
Affirm plus open question: "You've kept working at this even after regaining weight - that persistence matters. What would a version of activity that actually fits your week look like?" This reinforces effort and invites her to solve the problem, avoiding the righting reflex of prescribing before she is ready.
In each case, the goal is to elicit her own reasons and confidence rather than to persuade.
3. Co-create a two-week plan and a relapse plan, including one safety consideration given her knee pain.
Read the worked answer
Start with something she names as feasible: for example, a 10-minute walk after lunch three days this week, or a seated or water-based option if walking flares her knees. Choose the day and time with her, not for her, and identify one person who can join her or check in.
- Week 1: two or three 10-minute sessions. Self-monitor with a simple calendar or phone note.
- Week 2: if it went well, add one session or 5 minutes. Revisit at the next contact.
- Relapse plan: "If a week falls apart, that's information, not failure. We restart at 10 minutes." Ask her to identify her most likely barrier and a pre-decided response.
Safety: knee pain that is sharp, causes swelling, or persists beyond an hour after activity warrants assessment; otherwise favor low-impact activity, supportive shoes, and short bouts. Because she has prediabetes, no glucose monitoring is required unless she becomes symptomatic. Keep the focus on adherence and confidence, not on a perfect prescription.