Witnessed Collapse in a Fitness Center With a Single Rescuer
You are the only staff member on duty at a small fitness center at 6:15 a.m. A 58-year-old man collapses mid-stride on a treadmill and is unresponsive. You are alone in the room with him; two other members are on machines nearby but appear frozen. The front desk phone is 15 meters away. There is an AED mounted on the wall 20 meters in the opposite direction, and you have never opened it. The man is on his back on the floor between two treadmills, giving you about 1 meter of lateral working space. He is not breathing normally and you see occasional gasping.
1. List, in order, what you do in the first 60 seconds, and justify each action against the Chain of Survival.
Read the worked answer
- Verify unresponsiveness and breathing (tap and shout, look at chest for no more than ~10 seconds). Gasping is not normal breathing - treat as cardiac arrest. This is the recognition link.
- Activate the emergency response system and get the AED. Because you are alone with bystanders present, do NOT leave to call yourself. Point to a specific person: "You in the blue shirt - call 911 on speaker and come back and tell me you did it." Point to a second person: "You - get the AED off the wall and bring it here, turn it on." Naming individuals avoids diffusion of responsibility; the phone is far enough that leaving the patient costs compression time.
- Start chest compressions immediately rather than waiting for the AED. High-quality CPR is the priority; the AED arrives when it arrives. Begin at 100–120/min, at least 5 cm deep, full recoil.
- Apply the AED as soon as it arrives and follow prompts, minimizing interruptions. Key judgment: the single-rescuer rule is 'call first' for an adult, but with bystanders available you delegate instead of leaving - you never abandon compressions to make a phone call.
2. The AED arrives and prompts 'no shock advised.' One bystander asks whether that means the man's heart is fine and compressions can stop. How do you respond, and what do you do next?
Read the worked answer
A 'no shock advised' message means the AED did not detect a shockable rhythm (VF or pulseless VT). It does not mean there is a pulse or that the arrest is over - non-shockable rhythms (asystole, PEA) are common and still require CPR. There is no reason to stop compressions to check a pulse in a lay-provider/BLS context; you resume compressions immediately and continue cycles of 30:2 (or continuous compressions with a bag-mask if a second trained rescuer is ventilating). Reanalyze with the AED roughly every 2 minutes or whenever prompted, and swap compressors at that time to limit fatigue. The judgment tested: an AED's rhythm analysis is not a pulse check, and 'no shock' never justifies stopping CPR.
3. At minute 6 the man begins to move and breathe. You are still alone with untrained bystanders. What is your immediate post-arrest sequence, and what mistake are you most at risk of making?
Read the worked answer
Once spontaneous breathing and signs of life return (ROSC), stop compressions, place him in a recovery position (lateral) to protect the airway, keep the AED attached and powered on in case he rearrests, monitor breathing continuously, and keep the 911 call active / confirm EMS is en route with a clear location and access instructions. Do not give him anything by mouth. The most likely mistake is stopping monitoring - leaving him supine and unobserved, or removing the pads - because he 'looked better.' Rearrest is common in the first minutes; the AED should stay on and you should be ready to resume compressions instantly. A second common error is letting the bystanders disperse without sending someone to the door to guide EMS in.