Medical Director Stipend Above Fair Market Value
Riverside Community Hospital pays a 10-physician cardiology group $1.2 million annually for medical director services. Each physician is expected to provide four hours per month. The contract states compensation is set in advance at $2,500 per hour, has a one-year term, and says services include program development and quality oversight. No time logs or deliverables exist. An FMV survey in the file supports $200-$350 per hour for similar services. After the arrangement began, cardiology referrals to the hospital increased 18%. The compliance officer asks internal audit to assess the arrangement before the next contract renewal.
1. Assess the arrangement against the Stark Law and Anti-Kickback Statute. Identify which exceptions or safe harbors might apply and why they are likely unmet.
Read the worked answer
The arrangement should be evaluated as remuneration from a hospital to physicians who refer designated health services. Under the Stark personal-services exception, the agreement must be in writing and signed, have a term of at least one year, set compensation in advance at fair market value, be commercially reasonable, be necessary for the services, and not take into account volume or value of referrals. The written contract and term are present, but $2,500 per hour is far above the $200-$350 FMV range, there are no time logs or deliverables, and referrals rose 18%. Those facts undermine FMV and commercial reasonableness. The Anti-Kickback Statute personal-services safe harbor has similar requirements-written agreement, one-year term, set-in-advance FMV compensation, specified services, and no volume/value linkage. Because the safe harbor is not met, the arrangement creates AKS risk if any purpose was to induce referrals. Stark is strict liability; AKS requires intent, but the high payment and referral growth are red flags.
2. Recommend remediation, including whether to self-disclose to CMS and/or OIG. Calculate the approximate excess compensation.
Read the worked answer
Stop or restructure the arrangement immediately. Obtain an independent FMV appraisal, require documented time and deliverables, and recoup excess compensation. The excess over the top of the FMV range is approximately $1.03 million: ($2,500 − $350) × 4 hours × 12 months × 10 physicians. The total annual payment is $1.2 million, while FMV at $350/hour is $168,000. Because the facts suggest both Stark and AKS exposure, counsel should evaluate self-disclosure to the CMS Self-Referral Disclosure Protocol for Stark and the OIG Self-Disclosure Protocol for AKS, plus refund of affected claims. The 60-day Medicare overpayment rule may also apply once an overpayment is identified. Preserve documents, notify the board and insurer, and avoid destroying evidence. Disclosure is not automatic in every case, but the size, referral growth, and missing documentation make a privileged legal assessment essential.
3. Design ongoing monitoring for physician compensation arrangements.
Read the worked answer
Build a physician-arrangement compliance program: a central contract inventory with all terms, compensation, and deliverables; legal and compliance review before signature; annual FMV review by an independent appraiser; time logs and evidence of services; monitoring of referral volume and compensation-to-work ratios; and an audit clause. Use data analytics to flag outliers such as stipends per hour above FMV, referrals increasing after a contract, and contracts without documentation. Require annual attestations from physicians and department leaders, train them on Stark and AKS, and report results to the audit committee. Sample arrangements quarterly and track corrective actions.