The High-Risk Stop With a Passenger
At 2330 you attempt a traffic stop on a vehicle matching a broadcast for a car involved in a shots-fired call 20 minutes earlier. The vehicle stops in a residential cul-de-sac. As you approach, you see two occupants: a driver and a front passenger. The passenger's hands are not visible. The driver's window is down; the driver says 'we didn't do anything.' Backup is 3 minutes out. You are alone. The broadcast described a single male suspect, no passenger.
1. What do you do in the first 3 minutes before backup arrives, and why?
Read the worked answer
First 3 minutes:
- Do not approach alone into an unknown hands situation. Use your vehicle and lighting for cover/concealment; position for advantage.
- Give clear, calm commands to both occupants: driver hands on wheel, passenger hands visible on the dash. One set of commands at a time.
- Observe and report: watch hands, movements, and whether the passenger complies; relay to dispatch.
- Hold the stop until backup arrives rather than escalating solo.
- Assess the mismatch: broadcast said one male suspect; now there are two occupants. That is information, not proof of innocence or guilt.
Reasoning: The stop is high-risk because of the shots-fired nexus, but the broadcast is 20 minutes old and describes one suspect. Officer safety and information-gathering come before contact.
2. The passenger finally shows empty hands but the driver reaches toward the console. How do you respond?
Read the worked answer
Response:
- Give a single, loud, clear command: 'Driver, hands on the wheel now.'
- Watch the hands, not the face; a console reach is a common weapon-access movement.
- Do not fire or escalate solely on a reach; the response must match the threat you can articulate.
- If the driver does not comply and the reach continues, consider a higher-level command and, if backup is close, wait; if a weapon is seen, that changes the threat calculus under use-of-force policy.
- Communicate with backup about the movement.
Key: articulate the specific movement and why it mattered; avoid conclusory 'he reached.'
3. After backup arrives, how do you structure the contact given the broadcast mismatch?
Read the worked answer
Structure:
- High-risk stop protocol: one officer gives commands, others provide cover; occupants exit one at a time, hands visible, to a controlled position.
- Separate and control both occupants; pat-down for weapons consistent with policy and reasonable suspicion.
- Interview separately: where were they 20 minutes ago, who was driving, any knowledge of shots fired.
- Reconcile the broadcast: the description was one male; confirm identities and descriptions against the broadcast; a passenger does not clear the driver, and vice versa.
- Scene evidence: check the vehicle for casings, weapons, or damage consistent with shots fired; check the cul-de-sac.
Document the mismatch explicitly and how you resolved it.