Scope of Practice and Referral Obligations
Dr. Alan Reyes, a licensed chiropractor in Alabama, sees a 52-year-old male patient with acute low back pain radiating to the left leg, accompanied by numbness in the S1 dermatome and diminished ankle reflex. The patient also reports occasional loss of bladder control over the past two days. Dr. Reyes performs an adjustment and schedules a follow-up in one week. The patient returns with worsening symptoms, including increased numbness and difficulty urinating. Dr. Reyes decides to continue chiropractic care and does not refer the patient to a medical doctor. The patient's wife later files a complaint with the Alabama Board of Chiropractic Examiners, alleging that Dr. Reyes failed to recognize serious neurological symptoms and delayed necessary medical treatment.
1. Does Dr. Reyes's management of this patient fall within the scope of chiropractic practice in Alabama? Discuss the statutory boundaries and the standard of care regarding referral.
Read the worked answer
Chiropractic practice in Alabama is defined by statute (Ala. Code § 34-24-120 et seq.) as the diagnosis and treatment of human ailments by adjustment of the spinal column and other articulations, and by other procedures incidental thereto. However, the practice act explicitly excludes surgery, prescription of drugs, and the use of X-ray therapy for therapeutic purposes. More importantly, chiropractors are not permitted to treat conditions that are outside their scope or that require medical intervention. The standard of care requires recognizing red flags such as saddle anesthesia, bowel/bladder dysfunction, and progressive neurological deficits, which are indicative of cauda equina syndrome-a medical emergency. Dr. Reyes should have immediately referred the patient to an emergency department or a specialist. Failure to do so may constitute gross negligence or incompetence, grounds for discipline under Ala. Code § 34-24-160. The Board could find that Dr. Reyes exceeded the scope of chiropractic practice by attempting to manage a condition requiring urgent medical/surgical care, and that he violated the standard of care by not referring.
2. What are the potential disciplinary actions the Board might take against Dr. Reyes, and what factors would the Board consider in determining the appropriate sanction?
Read the worked answer
The Board may impose sanctions including reprimand, probation, suspension, revocation, or a civil penalty. Under Ala. Code § 34-24-160, the Board can discipline a licensee for gross negligence, incompetence, or failure to comply with the standard of care. The Board would consider: (1) the severity of the harm-the patient's condition worsened, indicating potential permanent damage; (2) whether Dr. Reyes had prior disciplinary history; (3) whether he demonstrated remorse or willingness to remediate; (4) the likelihood of recurrence; and (5) aggravating factors such as failure to document the neurological findings and failure to inform the patient of the need for medical referral. Because the failure to refer led to a delay in diagnosis and potential harm, the Board might impose a suspension, require additional education, and impose probation with monitoring. Mitigating factors could include cooperation with the investigation and absence of prior violations.