Advertising and Fee Disclosure for Discount Dental Plan
Dr. Lisa Wong owns a dental practice in Huntsville. She launches a marketing campaign offering a 'Dental Savings Plan' that advertises '50% off all services' for an annual membership fee of $99. The advertisement does not disclose that the 50% discount applies only to the practice's usual and customary fees, which are significantly higher than the local average. It also does not state that the plan is not insurance. A patient, Mr. Davis, signs up and later discovers that the discounted fee for a crown is still higher than the fee at a neighboring practice. He files a complaint with the Board alleging false advertising and failure to disclose fees.
1. Does Dr. Wong's advertisement violate Alabama Board rules on advertising and fee disclosure? Explain.
Read the worked answer
Yes. Alabama Board rules prohibit false, deceptive, or misleading advertising. Dr. Wong's advertisement claims '50% off all services' without clarifying that the discount is based on her own usual and customary fees, which may be inflated. This could mislead consumers into believing they are getting a bargain compared to market rates. Additionally, the ad fails to disclose that the plan is not insurance, which is required to avoid confusion. The Board requires that fee advertisements be accurate and not misleading. Dr. Wong's ad likely violates these rules. She could be subject to disciplinary action, including fines or required corrective advertising.
2. What should Dr. Wong have included in the advertisement to comply with the rules?
Read the worked answer
Dr. Wong should have included a clear disclaimer that the discount is based on the practice's usual and customary fees, and that those fees may be higher than other practices. She should have stated that the plan is not insurance. She should have provided a fee schedule or a link to one so consumers can compare. The advertisement should avoid absolute claims like '50% off all services' unless it is true for all services and clearly explained. She should also ensure that any savings claims are verifiable. By making these disclosures, Dr. Wong would comply with the Board's advertising rules and avoid misleading patients.