Aide, PTA, or PT? Delegation at a Skilled Nursing Facility
You are the supervising PT at a 120-bed skilled nursing facility. Your PTA, Marcus, is licensed and has 4 years of experience. Your rehab aide, Tanya, is unlicensed and has worked at the facility for 6 years. A new resident, Mr. H, is 3 days post-hip fracture ORIF, weight-bearing as tolerated, with a plan of care you wrote specifying gait training with a rolling walker and transfer training. You are double-booked and will be off-site at a meeting for 3 hours this afternoon. Marcus asks whether he can have Tanya 'run Mr. H through the gait training' because Marcus is covering 14 other residents. Tanya says she has done it 'a hundred times' and knows the resident well.
1. Can Tanya perform the gait training and transfer training for Mr. H? Analyze the delegation rules distinguishing PTA from aide roles.
Read the worked answer
No - Tanya cannot perform this. The distinction is structural, not experiential:
- PTA (Marcus): A licensed PTA may, under the supervising PT's direction and within the plan of care, carry out selected interventions - including gait and transfer training - for patients whose condition is stable or predictable, consistent with the PTA's competence and the supervision level the Board requires.
- Aide (Tanya): An unlicensed aide may perform only non-skilled, supportive tasks (e.g., transporting patients, setting up equipment, assisting with ambulation already established as safe, clerical duties). An aide may not independently deliver skilled interventions, make clinical judgments, progress a patient, or modify the plan of care. 'She's done it a hundred times' is not a legal basis for delegation.
Key risk factors here: Mr. H is 3 days post-ORIF - a fresh surgical patient with weight-bearing precautions and fall risk. This is not a stable, predictable situation appropriate for independent aide delivery. Having an aide 'run' the session converts skilled intervention into unlicensed practice and shifts liability to the supervising PT and facility.
Correct answer: Tanya may assist with setup/transport under direct line-of-sight, but the skilled gait/transfer training must be delivered by Marcus (PTA) or you (PT).
2. You cannot cancel the meeting. Design a compliant staffing plan for the 3-hour window and identify the documentation and supervision elements that must be in place.
Read the worked answer
Compliant plan options (pick one):
- Reschedule/defer Mr. H's skilled session to when you or Marcus can provide it. A 3-hour delay in a stable post-op patient is clinically acceptable; document the rationale.
- Reorder Marcus's schedule so he personally delivers Mr. H's session before you leave, with you on-site for the highest-risk portion.
- Reschedule the meeting or send a designee if Mr. H's status requires PT-level oversight.
Non-negotiable supervision/documentation elements:
- The plan of care must specify the intervention, frequency, and supervision level; any change in the resident's condition (e.g., new pain, dizziness, weight-bearing status change) requires PT re-evaluation, not aide improvisation.
- Marcus's session must be documented in the record, with your co-signature/review per facility and Board requirements for PTA-delivered care.
- Tanya's role, if any, must be limited to non-skilled assistance and documented as such.
- If a patient's condition is unstable or the PTA is uncertain, the PT must be available - off-site for 3 hours without a plan is itself a supervision gap.
Principle: delegation follows licensure and patient acuity, not staff convenience or seniority.