The Private Party and the Chauffeur Claim
A retirement party for 40 people is in the back room. The host has prepaid for wine and an open bar and has tipped generously. At 9:00 p.m., one guest-a 45-year-old man-is visibly intoxicated: he is stumbling, speaking loudly, and has spilled two glasses. He has had about six drinks over two and a half hours. The host pulls you aside and says, 'He's not driving-he has a chauffeur. It's a celebration, we prepaid, and I'll take full responsibility. Just keep serving him.' The man's glass is empty and he is gesturing at the bar. The host is a regular who books this room twice a year.
1. Does the chauffeur claim change your obligation to stop serving him?
Read the worked answer
No. In most jurisdictions and under standard house policy, a server may not serve a person who is visibly intoxicated. The presence of a driver reduces the risk of an impaired-driving crash but does not make continued service lawful or safe.
Why the claim does not resolve it:
- The 'chauffeur' is unverified-you have not seen a driver, and the guest may still drive later or leave with someone else.
- A visibly intoxicated person can be injured on the premises, become ill, or be involved in an altercation.
- The guest may continue drinking elsewhere after the party.
What the visible signs tell you: stumbling, loud speech, and spills are observable impairment. The estimate-six drinks in 2.5 hours for an average-sized man-would put him roughly around 0.10 or higher before elimination, consistent with what you see. The decision is based on observation, not the host's assurance.
2. The host says the bar is prepaid and offers to take responsibility. How do you respond, and what do you do?
Read the worked answer
Prepayment does not transfer the service decision to the host. The bar sold the package; the server still controls who is served. A host's promise to 'take responsibility' does not override the server's duty or the house's license obligations.
Say: 'I appreciate that, and I know this is a big night. But I can't keep serving someone who is visibly intoxicated-that's on me and the house, not something you can sign away. I'll get him water and something to eat, and I'll make sure he's not driving.'
Do:
- Cut off the guest politely and privately; do not make a spectacle.
- Offer water, food, and a seat away from the bar.
- Confirm the driver exists-ask the host to bring the driver to you or arrange a rideshare.
- Tell the manager; a host who books repeatedly may push back, and the manager should hear it from you first.
- Document the cut-off time, observations, host's request, and what you arranged.
Reasoning: the host's pressure is predictable and not personal. The answer is consistent: no more alcohol for that guest, and a safe exit plan.
3. What if the host insists and says, 'Then we'll just leave and go to another bar'?
Read the worked answer
Let them leave, but do not pour another drink. You cannot control what another licensed business does, and you should not try to bargain by serving 'one last' drink to keep them on site.
What you can do:
- Make sure the intoxicated guest is not the driver; if the group leaves on foot or by arranged ride, note it.
- If the guest is about to drive, follow house policy-manager intervention, offer a ride, call police if necessary.
- Tell the manager what happened, including the host's threat, so the next shift and the booking manager know.
- Document factually: 'At 9:10 p.m., service refused to guest X; host requested continued service and stated they would leave; group departed at 9:25 p.m. via [ride/on foot].'
Reasoning: the threat to leave is a pressure tactic, not a reason to serve. Your obligation ends at your door, but your documentation should show you recognized the risk and acted reasonably.