Ethical Dilemma: Involuntary Treatment
Ms. T, a 42-year-old woman with bipolar I disorder, is brought to the emergency department by police after she was found running in traffic, shouting that she is a deity. She is disoriented, agitated, and refuses examination. Her roommate reports she stopped taking lithium 2 weeks ago and has not slept in 3 days. She has no advance directive. The treatment team believes she needs involuntary psychiatric admission and medication. The nurse is asked to participate in the decision.
1. What ethical principles are in conflict in this situation, and how should the nurse balance them?
Read the worked answer
The conflict is between autonomy (Ms. T's right to refuse treatment) and beneficence/nonmaleficence (the duty to act in her best interest and prevent harm). Because she is acutely manic, disoriented, and a danger to herself (running in traffic), she likely lacks decision-making capacity. The nurse should:
- Assess capacity: Can she understand the risks and benefits of treatment? Is she able to communicate a choice?
- Follow state law for involuntary commitment and emergency treatment.
- Act in her best interest while respecting her dignity and rights.
- Document the assessment and rationale.
- Involve family if appropriate, respecting privacy laws.
The nurse should advocate for the least restrictive intervention that ensures safety, such as emergency medication and admission, while planning for her participation in treatment as she improves.
2. What is the nurse's role in the involuntary admission process?
Read the worked answer
The nurse's role includes:
- Ensuring due process: verifying that the legal criteria for involuntary admission are met (e.g., danger to self/others, grave disability).
- Documenting the patient's behavior and statements that justify the hold.
- Advocating for the patient's rights: informing her of her rights, including the right to legal counsel and to appeal.
- Providing safe care: managing agitation, preventing harm, and administering emergency treatment as ordered.
- Collaborating with the treatment team, legal counsel, and family.
- Maintaining confidentiality per HIPAA.
The nurse should also ensure that restraint or seclusion, if used, follows facility policy and is time-limited with frequent monitoring.