The Free-Withdrawal Illusion
A 59-year-old client, Denise, buys a fixed indexed annuity with a $150,000 premium. The contract has a 10% free-withdrawal provision, a 9-year surrender schedule starting at 8%, and a market value adjustment. In year 2, Denise requests a $20,000 withdrawal, believing the 10% free-withdrawal amount applies. The agent tells her "10% is 10%, you're fine." The contract's free-withdrawal provision actually calculates the 10% on the beginning-of-year account value, and the withdrawal is taken mid-year after a 4% index credit. The surrender charge in year 2 is 7%, and an MVA applies because rates have risen since purchase. Denise also has a 1% annual administrative fee deducted quarterly.
1. Calculate whether Denise's $20,000 withdrawal is fully within the free-withdrawal amount, and identify what charges apply.
Read the worked answer
The free-withdrawal amount is 10% of the beginning-of-year account value, not of the mid-year value after the index credit.
- Beginning-of-year account value: assume $150,000 (year 2 start). 10% free-withdrawal = $15,000.
- Denise requests $20,000, so $5,000 exceeds the free-withdrawal amount.
- The excess $5,000 is subject to the year-2 surrender charge of 7% = $350, plus an MVA on the excess (the MVA percentage depends on the contract formula and rate movement; it could add or subtract value - here rates rose, so it likely reduces the amount).
- The 1% administrative fee is deducted separately and does not change the free-withdrawal calculation, but it reduces the account value and therefore the dollar amount of the 10%.
So the agent's "10% is 10%" statement is wrong: only $15,000 is free; $5,000 incurs surrender charges and MVA. The mid-year index credit does not increase the free-withdrawal allowance because the provision is measured on the beginning-of-year value.
2. What consumer-protection and sales-practice problems does the agent's statement create, and how should the transaction be handled?
Read the worked answer
Problems:
- Misrepresentation of contract terms. Telling the client "10% is 10%, you're fine" misstates how the free-withdrawal provision is calculated and understates the charges. This is a sales-practice violation (misrepresentation/omission of material contract terms).
- Failure to disclose surrender charge and MVA. The client was not told that the excess $5,000 would incur a 7% surrender charge and an MVA.
- Inadequate needs/liquidity analysis at sale. If Denise expected to withdraw $20,000 in year 2, the product's liquidity terms should have been explained and documented at purchase.
Handling: Before processing, the agent should correct the record, disclose the $15,000 free amount, the $5,000 excess, the 7% charge ($350), and the MVA, and let Denise decide whether to proceed, reduce the withdrawal to $15,000, or wait. The correction and the client's decision should be documented. The supervisor should review the agent's conduct and remediate any prior misstatement.
3. If Denise instead waited until year 3, how would the analysis change, and what general principle about free-withdrawal provisions should the agent have communicated?
Read the worked answer
Year 3: The surrender charge drops (e.g., to 6% on a 9-year 8%-declining schedule), and the free-withdrawal amount resets to 10% of the year-3 beginning-of-year account value, which is larger after the year-2 index credit and net of the 1% admin fee. So waiting both increases the free-withdrawal dollar amount and reduces the surrender charge on any excess. The MVA may still apply depending on rate movement.
General principle to communicate: Free-withdrawal provisions are not simply "10% of whatever you have." The agent must explain: (a) the measurement date (beginning-of-year vs. current value), (b) whether the free amount is cumulative or use-it-or-lose-it, (c) that excess withdrawals trigger surrender charges and MVA, (d) the order of withdrawal (free amount first, then charged amounts), and (e) how index credits and fees affect the calculation. The client should receive a clear written explanation at sale and again before any withdrawal.