Distortion and Fit-Up on a Thin-Walled Stainless Frame
You are fabricating a rectangular frame from 1.6 mm thick 304 stainless steel tube, 40 mm x 40 mm, with mitred corners. The drawing specifies a 1 mm maximum gap at the joints and a finished diagonal tolerance of +/-2 mm over 1200 mm. Your first two frames pull 4 mm out of square after welding, and the mitre faces show a visible gap of about 2 mm on one side. The TIG set is running at 55 A with a 1.6 mm filler, and the fitter says the saw is cutting slightly off angle. The job is due tomorrow and there is no spare tube.
1. Identify the likely causes of the out-of-square result and explain how fit-up contributes to it.
Read the worked answer
The 4 mm diagonal error is a distortion problem, not a single-cause fault. Thin stainless has high thermal expansion and low thermal conductivity, so heat stays local and contraction on cooling pulls the joint. Contributing factors here include: the 2 mm gap at the mitre, which requires extra filler and extra heat to bridge, increasing shrinkage; welding sequence that concentrates heat on one side; and the saw cutting off angle, which means the joint faces do not close evenly and the welder compensates with more metal.
The gap matters because a 2 mm gap on 1.6 mm wall is larger than the 1 mm allowed and forces the arc to bridge rather than fuse. That increases heat input and shrinkage on that corner, which is consistent with the frame pulling consistently in one direction. The off-angle saw is therefore both a quality and a distortion cause, and fixing only the welding technique would leave the root cause in place.
2. Describe the corrective actions you would take before welding the next frame, and how you would control distortion during welding.
Read the worked answer
First correct the fit-up: adjust or service the saw so mitres close to within 1 mm, and check the cut angle with a square before cutting the remaining stock. If a small gap remains, close it mechanically rather than filling it with weld.
For distortion control: tack the frame square, checking diagonals before welding; use a balanced back-step or alternating sequence, welding opposite corners in turn so shrinkage opposes itself; keep the heat input low with a sharp arc, minimal weave and the smallest adequate current; allow each joint to cool before the next; and consider a temporary brace or clamp across the diagonals until the frame is complete. After welding, check the diagonals and record the result. If a frame is outside tolerance, the decision is whether it can be corrected within the drawing requirements, not whether to ship it and hope.