De-escalating an Intoxicated Patron at the Barrier
During a busy show, a man in his thirties at the front barrier is shouting at a woman beside him and has pushed her twice. He is swaying, slurring, and has a fresh graze on his knuckle. When you approach, he turns on you, jabs a finger at your chest and says, 'Touch me and I'll have your job, I know my rights.' Around 30 patrons are now watching, some filming on phones. The woman is crying and wants to leave but is boxed in by the crowd. Your colleague is 10 metres away and can be with you in 20 seconds. The barrier is 1.2 metres high and the crowd behind is dense. Use of force policy permits reasonable force to remove a person refusing to leave.
1. Set out your de-escalation approach and the specific communication you would use in the first 60 seconds.
Read the worked answer
The aim is to separate, lower the temperature, and move him out of a dense crowd where any physical intervention is high-risk.
First 60 seconds:
- Create space and a second body: signal your colleague over before speaking; never manage an agitated, intoxicated person alone in a crowd. Position so you are side-on, not squared up, with an exit route behind you.
- Attend to the woman first in a calm, low voice - get her moved out through the barrier gap to welfare. Removing the person he is focused on often defuses the confrontation.
- Acknowledge, don't argue: 'I'm not going to touch you. I need to talk to you about what happened.' Avoid contesting his rights claim; arguing about rights is a trap. You can say: 'You're right that I can't just grab you. I'm asking you to come with me to the side so we can sort this out.'
- Give a clear choice with a consequence: 'You can come with me now and we'll talk, or if you stay and keep pushing people, I'll have to remove you. I'd rather you came with me.'
- Use his name if known, keep voice low and slow, avoid crowding, avoid touching until necessary.
- Ignore the filming - behave as if it will be reviewed, because it will.
If he complies, walk him out with your colleague on his other side. If he does not, that is the point at which force policy becomes relevant - not before.
2. He refuses to leave and squares up to you. What justifies force here, what force is proportionate, and what must you do afterwards?
Read the worked answer
Justification: he has assaulted a patron (two pushes), is refusing a lawful instruction to leave, and is in a dense crowd where his behaviour risks a surge. The venue's use-of-force policy permits reasonable force to remove a person refusing to leave. The legal test is necessity and proportionality - the minimum force to achieve the removal.
Proportionate force: a two-person, controlled escort - one steward each side, guiding by the upper arms - out through the nearest exit, with a third steward clearing a path and watching for the crowd reaction. Avoid neck, throat, and joint locks; avoid taking him to the ground in a packed crowd, which risks injury to bystanders and to him. If he goes limp or actively fights, stop, create space, and call police rather than escalating in the crowd.
Afterwards:
- Hand him to police if attending, or remove him from the premises and ensure he is not left in a vulnerable state; note his intoxication.
- Check on the woman, take her account, and offer welfare support.
- Complete an incident report the same night: times, witnesses, force used, injuries, body-worn camera or CCTV references.
- Preserve CCTV and identify the filming patrons.
- Notify the duty manager and record any injury to staff.
The judgement tested is that force is the last step, minimal, witnessed, and documented.