A student midwife's error and the duty to be honest
You are the supervising midwife for a second-year student on a postnatal ward. The student administered a dose of anti-D immunoglobulin to a woman who had already received it earlier that shift. The error was discovered when you checked the medication chart 20 minutes later. The woman is well, with no signs of reaction, and the dose is not immediately dangerous, but it was unnecessary. The student is tearful and asks you not to tell the woman or the ward manager because she fears being removed from the course. The woman is awake and asking why two midwives were looking at her chart.
1. What are your immediate obligations to the woman, the student, and the record, and how do they interact?
Read the worked answer
The woman must be told what happened. She is awake and asking questions, and concealment would breach the duty of openness and her right to know about her care. Explain in plain terms that she received an additional dose of anti-D, that it was not needed, that the risk to her is low, and what will be monitored. Answer her questions and apologise on behalf of the team without blaming the student at the bedside.
The student's request cannot be granted, and she needs to hear that clearly and kindly. Explain that honesty is a professional obligation, that hiding the error would harm the woman and would be far worse for the student's standing than reporting it, and that the purpose of reporting is learning and patient safety. Reassure her that a single error reported openly is usually handled through support and education, not punishment.
Record the event factually: the drug, dose, time, route, who administered it, how it was discovered, the woman's condition, the discussion with her, and the actions taken. Complete an incident report through the local system. Inform the ward manager and the student's link tutor or practice educator, as required by the placement's policy. Do not promise the student confidentiality that you cannot keep.
2. How would you handle the student's fear and the possibility that she may be removed from the course, while maintaining your own accountability?
Read the worked answer
Separate the two issues. The woman's safety and honesty about the error are non-negotiable; the student's future is important but is decided through a different process. Tell the student what you will do and when, so she is not surprised: you will inform the ward manager and the practice educator, complete an incident report, and support her to reflect on what happened.
Explore the cause without turning it into an interrogation. Was the chart unclear, was there a double-check policy that was not followed, was she rushed, or did she not understand the anti-D schedule? These answers shape the learning plan and may reveal a systems problem rather than only an individual one. Ask her to write a reflective account and offer to go with her to the meeting with her tutor.
Your own accountability is to report accurately and promptly, not to protect a colleague or a student from consequences. You should also be honest about your own role in supervision: were you available, did you check the chart in time, should the double-check have been in place? Record this. If the student's fitness to practise is later questioned, your contemporaneous, factual documentation will be the fairest record for everyone. Avoid predicting the outcome; say what the process is and what support is available.