The Student's Family History and the Class Presentation
In a Year 12 Aboriginal Studies class, students must present a 5-minute talk on 'continuity and change in a local Aboriginal community'. One Aboriginal student, who has family connections in the town, is asked by classmates to 'just tell us what your family thinks'. The student has previously told the teacher privately that their family does not discuss certain topics, including a relative's removal as a child. Another student plans to present on the Stolen Generations using a documentary clip showing interviews with survivors. The teacher has 3 lessons before presentations. The class has 19 students. The school has a policy that sensitive content requires advance notice to parents, but the teacher has not sent it.
1. Advise the teacher on how to handle the Aboriginal student's situation and the classmates' request.
Read the worked answer
The teacher must protect the student from being positioned as a representative of their family or community.
Actions:
- Address the class request directly, without singling out the student: no student is expected to speak for their family or community; sources are community organisations, published accounts and guest speakers.
- Speak with the student privately before the next lesson, confirming what they are comfortable with and offering an alternative topic or format.
- Set a class norm: presenters speak from research, not from personal disclosure; personal experience is shared only if the student chooses.
- Provide alternative sources so the class has real material: local land council, language centre, oral history collections with consent.
Reasoning: asking an Aboriginal student to 'tell us what your family thinks' turns them into an informant and can expose private grief. Self-determination applies to students too. The teacher's job is to create a safe structure, not to extract content.
2. The documentary clip includes survivor interviews. What should the teacher do about the school's sensitive-content policy and about student wellbeing?
Read the worked answer
Policy: the teacher should send the advance notice now, three lessons out, naming the topic and the nature of the content and offering parents a conversation. If the policy requires more notice, the teacher should seek an exemption or move the presentation later rather than proceed silently.
Wellbeing:
- Warn students before the clip; allow them to step out without explanation.
- Avoid showing graphic material; choose a clip that centres survivor voice and resilience, not only trauma.
- Have a follow-up discussion and a known support person available.
- Check privately with any student likely to be affected, including the Aboriginal student, without assuming they need protection.
The reasoning: sensitive content is legitimate curriculum, but the school owes students predictability and care. Notice to parents is not about censorship; it lets families prepare. Proceeding without notice breaches policy and trust.