HSC Latin Continuers study materials
HSC Latin Continuers study resources

Comprehension Under a Lexical Gap

HSC Latin Continuers · Put your knowledge to work in context.

All case studies

Comprehension Under a Lexical Gap

In an unseen passage from a prose author, a student meets an unfamiliar noun used twice: once as the subject of a verb of fearing and once inside a purpose clause introduced by ut. The student knows the verb of fearing takes a subjunctive in a noun clause, and knows ut can introduce purpose or result. Two other clauses in the passage contain subjunctives, one after cum and one after a relative pronoun. The student has 40 minutes for the whole passage and has already spent 12 on this sentence. The teacher requires a translation that is grammatically defensible even where the exact meaning of the unknown noun is uncertain.

1. Explain how the student should handle the unknown noun without stalling, and what grammatical clues constrain its meaning.

Read the worked answer

The student should assign a placeholder ("the X") and keep translating, then use context to narrow it. The first occurrence, as subject of a verb of fearing, tells us the noun is a thing or person that can be feared; the second, inside a purpose clause with ut plus subjunctive, tells us it is something that can be sought or avoided. Because ut after a verb of fearing clause is not purpose but the feared outcome, the student must check which verb governs which ut. The cum clause and the relative clause are separate subjunctives and should not be attached to the unknown noun. Spending more time is inefficient; a defensible gloss plus a note is better than a blank.

2. Draft the translation strategy for the sentence in 25 words or more, showing how you would render both clauses.

Read the worked answer

Render the fearing clause as "he feared that the X would..." with subjunctive, and the ut clause as the feared outcome rather than purpose; keep the placeholder consistent, then revise once the surrounding narrative clarifies whether the noun is hostile or desired.