Reading the Job Advertisement
Your class is given three short Serbian texts about summer work and asked which one you would apply for. Text A is a hotel in Zlatibor advertising for a waiter: it stresses a friendly team, accommodation included, and pay 'dogovor' (by agreement). Text B is a Belgrade call centre offering a fixed hourly rate, a precise schedule, and a requirement for 'odlično poznavanje srpskog i engleskog jezika'. Text C is a family farm near Subotica offering seasonal fruit-picking, payment per kilogram picked, and free meals. Each text uses emotive language: Text A says 'postanite deo naše porodice', Text B says 'mi gradimo budućnost zajedno', Text C says 'sveže voće i poštena zarada'. Your teacher asks you to look past the slogans and judge which advertisement gives you the most reliable information and which best suits a student who needs predictable income.
1. Compare the three advertisements for how much verifiable information each provides. Support your judgement with specific words from the texts.
Read the worked answer
Model answer should separate verifiable facts from promotional language. (1) Text B is the most verifiable: it states an hourly rate, a schedule, and a concrete language requirement, so a reader can calculate earnings and check eligibility. (2) Text A is the least verifiable on pay: dogovor means the figure is unknown until negotiation, and 'accommodation included' does not say whether it is shared, free, or deducted; the phrase postanite deo naše porodice is relational advertising, not information. (3) Text C is partly verifiable: pay per kilogram is a formula, but the reader cannot know the rate per kilogram, the daily volume, or whether bad weather reduces work, so income is variable; poštena zarada is an assertion, not a number. (4) The slogan mi gradimo budućnost zajedno in Text B signals team culture but adds no contractual detail. Top-band answers quote the Serbian phrases, distinguish fact from claim, and note the missing variable in each case rather than just ranking them.
2. A classmate says Text C is best because 'poštena zarada' shows the employer is honest. Write a 70-100 word response in Serbian challenging this reasoning.
Read the worked answer
Model answer should: (1) Name the reasoning error - an adjective describing honesty is not evidence of honesty; to što piše ,poštena zarada' ne dokazuje da je zarada poštena. (2) Point to what is missing: the rate per kilogram, the expected daily quantity, and what happens on rainy days. (3) Contrast with a checkable claim: Text B's hourly rate can be multiplied by hours. (4) Offer a practical test: telephone the farm and ask three specific questions before agreeing. (5) Use appropriate Serbian structures: zarada po kilogramu, po kilogramu ubranog voća, conditional ako biste mi rekli, and comparative forms. High marks require the response to be persuasive and polite, not just a list of doubts; it should also concede that per-kilogram work can be fair for a fast picker.