The Unpaid Trial Shift
Sofia owns a small florist shop. She advertises for a casual sales assistant. Three applicants are invited to a "trial" of four hours each on a busy Saturday. They arrange flowers, serve customers, and process two online orders. Sofia tells them the trial is unpaid because "it's a chance to show what you can do" and that she will choose one person afterwards. All three complete the shift. One, Amara, later asks to be paid for the four hours. Sofia refuses, saying Amara was not an employee and the shift was a test. Amara points out she served paying customers and handled stock. Sofia says if Amara keeps asking, she will not be considered for the job.
1. Analyse whether the trial shifts should be treated as work, and identify the workplace practices issues raised.
Read the worked answer
Is it work? The indicators point strongly toward an employment relationship for the shift. Amara performed productive tasks that benefited the business - serving paying customers and processing real orders. She was directed by Sofia, on Sofia's premises, during Sofia's trading hours. The label "trial" does not determine the character of the arrangement; the substance does. A genuine skills assessment is short, structured, and does not generate revenue. A four-hour Saturday shift on a busy trading day does generate revenue.
Issues raised:
Unpaid work. If the shift is employment, it must be paid at the applicable rate. Using unpaid labour to staff a busy Saturday shifts a business cost onto applicants.
Power imbalance and coercion. Linking payment to continued consideration for the job - "if you keep asking, you won't be considered" - is a retaliatory response to a lawful query. It pressures a candidate to surrender an entitlement to keep a job prospect.
Fair process. Running three people through full shifts and selecting one means two people worked for nothing. A fair process assesses candidates without extracting free labour.
Reputation and compliance risk. Word travels in small towns and among casual job networks.
2. Recommend what Sofia should do now, and how she should design future recruitment.
Read the worked answer
Immediate remediation:
- Pay all three applicants for the four hours at the applicable casual rate, including any casual loading. Record the payments properly.
- Withdraw the threat about Amara's candidacy. A candidate's request to be paid must not affect selection. If Sofia cannot separate the two, she should step back from the decision.
- Apologise briefly and factually. A short acknowledgment reduces the risk of escalation far more than defending the position.
Future recruitment design:
- Replace full unpaid shifts with a short, clearly bounded assessment - for example, a 30-minute practical task using sample stock, or a structured interview with scenario questions.
- If a paid trial is genuinely useful, make it paid, time-limited, and explained in writing before the day: duration, rate, supervision, and what is being assessed.
- State in the advertisement what the process involves so applicants can consent with full information.
Principle: A recruitment process should not transfer business costs to applicants. The test is simple - if the business earns money from the activity, the person doing it should be paid. Selection should rest on demonstrated capability, not on willingness to work unpaid.