Night Shift Fatigue and the Unlogged Door Alarm
You are the sole operator on a 19:00–07:00 shift at a distribution centre control room. Your colleague called in sick, so you are covering a double shift after only three hours of sleep. At 03:40 a door-contact alarm on the goods-in corridor chimes. You acknowledge it, see no camera coverage of that corridor because the camera has been offline for two weeks, and note a contractor badge was last used at 03:12. You are due to hand over at 07:00 and the supervisor is unavailable by phone. Your eyelids are heavy and you have already missed two radio check-ins in the past hour.
1. Identify the fatigue-related risks in this situation and explain what you should do immediately, including whom to notify and what to record.
Read the worked answer
The core risks are impaired vigilance, delayed alarm acknowledgement, and a single point of failure. Missing two radio check-ins is objective evidence that your attention has already degraded, not just a feeling of tiredness. Acknowledging a door alarm with no camera coverage means you cannot verify visually, so the alarm must be treated as unverified until someone physically checks.
Immediate actions:
- Acknowledge and escalate the alarm. Log the time, zone, and that the camera is offline. Dispatch a guard or ask the site supervisor to physically check the goods-in corridor. Do not close the alarm as 'false' without verification.
- Notify someone with authority. If the supervisor is unreachable, escalate to the next on-call manager or the security company duty officer. Report the missed check-ins and the double shift honestly.
- Make a fatigue report. Record the double shift, sleep amount, and symptoms in the handover log so the relief operator and management know the control room was staffed below safe levels.
- Use countermeasures you control. Stand up, move, hydrate, increase lighting, and do a deliberate radio check with the guard force. These reduce but do not remove risk.
- Request relief. Ask for the relief operator to come in early or for a guard to sit with you. If no relief is possible, request permission to reduce non-critical tasks and focus on alarms and radio.
The judgement point is that you cannot 'try harder' your way out of fatigue. The correct answer escalates the staffing failure and refuses to let an unverified alarm pass.
2. The contractor badge used at 03:12 belongs to a person who signed out at 22:00 the previous evening. What does this suggest, and what should you do about it?
Read the worked answer
A badge used after its holder signed out suggests one of several things: tailgating or badge sharing, a cloned or lost card, a records error, or an intruder using a found card. It is not automatically a break-in, but it is a genuine anomaly that must be investigated.
Actions:
- Preserve the access-control log for that door and badge for the relevant period, and note the exact timestamps.
- Check the badge holder's status with the contractor's supervisor: did they leave site, hand in the badge, or report it lost?
- Review any available footage of the goods-in area from other cameras, even partial coverage, and check neighbouring doors for the same badge.
- Send a guard to physically inspect the corridor and confirm the door is secure.
- Record everything in the incident log and hand it to the duty manager. If the badge cannot be accounted for, treat it as a possible intrusion and consider deactivating the credential.
The reasoning is that a badge event is only as reliable as the credential's custody. The operator's job is to preserve evidence, verify, and escalate, not to conclude.