Listening: Inferring Attitude from Prosody and Hesitation
Students listen twice to a 90-second recording of a radio interview. A woman describes moving to a new city. Her words are mostly positive: 'העיר יפה', 'יש כאן אנשים נחמדים'. However, she pauses before saying 'השכונות... כן, יש שכונות טובות', laughs briefly after 'המחירים סבירים', and slows down when mentioning 'התחבורה הציבורית'. The question asks: 'What is the speaker's attitude toward living in the city?' One student answers 'completely positive' because of the words used. Another answers 'negative' because of the pauses. The rubric awards marks for 'identifying attitude supported by evidence from tone and content'. The recording contains no explicit statement of dissatisfaction.
1. Explain why 'completely positive' and 'negative' are both weak answers, and what a stronger answer would claim.
Read the worked answer
The words are positive but the delivery signals reservation. The pause before 'השכונות' and the laugh after 'המחירים סבירים' suggest the speaker is choosing her words carefully rather than expressing unqualified enthusiasm. The slowdown on public transport hints at a concern she does not state outright. 'Completely positive' ignores prosodic evidence; 'negative' overstates it, since she never says she dislikes the city. A stronger answer is 'generally positive but with reservations', supported by both the positive adjectives and the hesitations. The rubric asks for attitude supported by tone and content, so the answer must cite at least one prosodic cue and one lexical cue. This is inference, not recall: the student must weigh conflicting signals.
2. List two specific pieces of evidence a student should cite, and explain how each supports the nuanced answer.
Read the worked answer
First, the brief laugh after 'המחירים סבירים'. Laughter in this position often marks irony or discomfort, suggesting the claim about prices is not fully sincere. It supports the idea that she has doubts about cost of living. Second, the slowdown before 'התחבורה הציבורית'. A slower delivery on a specific topic usually signals that the speaker is uncertain or reluctant, so public transport is likely a weak point for her. Together these cues qualify the positive adjectives and justify 'generally positive with reservations'. Students should also note the pause before 'השכונות', which suggests she is selecting a safe example rather than speaking spontaneously. Citing delivery features alongside words is what distinguishes a top-band listening response.