The Lift That Wasn't Booked
Priya is a 19-year-old student on placement at a community day centre. Her supervisor, Ken, asks her to help transfer 82-year-old Mervyn, who weighs about 95 kg and has left-sided weakness after a stroke, from his wheelchair to a therapy chair. The mechanical hoist is in the storeroom but its sling is being laundered and will not return until tomorrow. Ken says, 'We do it manually all the time, it's only two metres, and he's been fine before.' Mervyn says he is 'sick of waiting' and wants to be moved now. Priya has completed manual handling training but has never performed a two-person lift without a hoist. There are two other staff on shift, both busy with morning medication rounds. It is 10:40 am and Mervyn's daughter is due to arrive at 11:00 am.
1. Identify the hazards in this situation and explain what Priya should do, referring to the hierarchy of control and her obligations as a student on placement.
Read the worked answer
Hazards: (1) Mervyn's weight combined with unilateral weakness means he cannot reliably bear weight or assist, so a manual lift loads the worker's spine with most of 95 kg; (2) the hoist is unavailable, so the workplace's preferred higher-order control is missing; (3) Ken is applying pressure to improvise; (4) only two staff are available and one is an inexperienced student; (5) time pressure from the daughter's visit encourages shortcuts.
Hierarchy of control applied: Elimination would be postponing the transfer until the sling returns. Substitution means using a slide sheet or transfer board with Mervyn's cooperation if he can weight-bear at all. Engineering controls include the hoist. Administrative controls include a documented two-person manual handling procedure with training. PPE is last and least effective. A manual lift should only occur where a risk assessment permits it, and Priya has no evidence one does.
Priya's obligations: Under WHS law she must take reasonable care of her own and others' safety, follow instructions and report hazards. As a student she is not expected to absorb risk because she is 'junior'. She should decline the manual lift politely but clearly, explain the risk in plain language, and propose alternatives: wait for the sling, use a slide sheet with a second trained staff member, or ask Ken to complete a risk assessment before proceeding. She should record the request and her response in the shift notes and, if Ken insists, escalate to the placement coordinator or WHS representative. Declining an unsafe task is not misconduct; being pressured into it is the employer's failure.
2. Ken later tells Priya she is 'being difficult' and that refusing will be noted on her placement report. Discuss how Priya should respond and what supports exist.
Read the worked answer
Priya should separate the personal criticism from the safety issue. She can say, 'I'm not refusing to help Mervyn; I'm asking us to use a safe method.' This reframes the conflict as a shared problem rather than insubordination.
Practical steps: (1) Ask Ken to show her the risk assessment or procedure that authorises a manual lift; if none exists, the request is unsupported. (2) Offer a workable alternative so Mervyn still gets moved. (3) Write a factual, non-emotional record of the request, time, and her response the same day. (4) Raise the matter with her placement coordinator or the RTO's placement supervisor, because assessment of a student must be based on competence, not on compliance with unsafe directions. (5) If the pressure continues, use the workplace's hazard reporting or grievance process, or contact the regulator's advisory line.
Supports: The placement provider's WHS officer, the RTO placement coordinator, WorkSafe-style advisory services, and the student's union or placement support officer. Retaliation for raising a safety concern is itself a breach of WHS duties, so a threat to alter a report is serious. Priya should keep copies of all communications. The key judgement is that a poor placement report does not make an unsafe lift acceptable, and documentation protects her if the story is later disputed.