A resident with dementia who refuses a shower
Mr Adeyemi is 84, has moderate dementia and speaks English as a second language. He has been on the ward for five days after a urinary tract infection. His care plan says 'shower daily, assist of one'. It is day three and he has refused every shower, becoming agitated and raising his fist when staff approach. His daughter visits at 4:00 pm and has told you he has always been private about his body and was a teacher who values being addressed formally. He has a faint odour and his skin folds are reddened. The RN is asking you to 'get him showered before his daughter arrives'.
1. How would you balance the RN's instruction with Mr Adeyemi's rights and his clinical needs?
Read the worked answer
The instruction to shower him before his daughter arrives is not clinically necessary and risks escalating his agitation. Mr Adeyemi retains rights to dignity, privacy and to refuse care unless he lacks capacity for that specific decision and a lawful substitute decision-maker agrees.
Balance the competing needs:
- Clinical: skin-fold redness and odour suggest he needs hygiene, but a full shower is not the only option. A bed bath, washing the skin folds, a change of clothes and clean linen meet the immediate need with less threat.
- Rights and communication: address him formally as Mr Adeyemi, explain each step, offer choices (wash now or after lunch; which cloth; whether he wants a male or female staff member), and use a familiar routine from his teaching days.
- Escalation: if refusal persists, document it, inform the RN, and ask for a capacity assessment and a behaviour support plan rather than forcing care.
Reasoning: forcing a shower after a raised fist is a restraint and an assault risk. Meeting hygiene needs by the least restrictive means protects both his dignity and staff safety.
2. Describe how you would communicate with the daughter when she arrives, and what you would and would not say.
Read the worked answer
Speak with her privately, use a calm tone and start with what is going well: 'Your father has been settled today and his infection is improving.'
Say:
- That he has declined showers and you are respecting his choice while offering alternatives such as bed baths.
- That you have noticed some skin redness and are monitoring it with the RN.
- That her knowledge of his routines and preferences is valuable, and ask what has helped at home.
- That a review of his care plan and a capacity assessment may occur.
Do not:
- Blame him or describe him as difficult.
- Share other residents' information or detailed clinical results.
- Promise that he will be showered by a certain time.
- Discuss his body privacy in a way that embarrasses the family.
Reasoning: families need honest, respectful information and a role. Framing refusal as a communication and care-planning issue keeps trust and may reveal strategies, such as a male carer or a preferred time, that resolve the problem. Document the conversation and any new preferences in the care plan.