The Conflict of Interest in a Property Dispute
A Queensland law firm acts for a husband and wife in the purchase of an investment property. The wife later consults the same firm about a divorce and says she wants to claim the property as hers alone. The firm's principal, who handled the purchase, is asked to act for the wife in the family law matter. The husband has not consented. The firm also holds the couple's joint file, which contains advice about the property's ownership. The principal asks you, as the junior solicitor, whether the firm can act for the wife and what must be done with the joint file. The wife says she does not want the husband to know about the consultation. The husband has not been informed of the divorce.
1. Can the firm act for the wife in the family law matter?
Read the worked answer
The firm has a conflict of interest. It acted for both spouses jointly in the purchase, and the joint file contains information relevant to the ownership dispute. Acting for the wife against the husband in a matter arising from the same property would involve using confidential information obtained in the joint retainer and would be adverse to the former client. The firm cannot act for the wife without the husband's informed consent, which has not been given. Even with consent, the firm must consider whether it can act fairly and whether the joint file can be protected. The principal's personal involvement in the purchase increases the risk. The firm should decline to act for the wife in the family law matter and should advise her to obtain independent legal advice. The firm must not disclose the wife's consultation to the husband without her consent, but it must also protect the husband's confidential information. The conflict is not cured by the wife's request for confidentiality.
2. What should be done with the joint file and the information in it?
Read the worked answer
The joint file is held for both clients, and each is entitled to access to the joint file, but the firm must not use information from the joint retainer against either client. The firm should preserve the file, maintain confidentiality, and not disclose its contents to either spouse without consent or a legal obligation. If the wife seeks the file, the firm should consider whether providing it would breach the husband's confidentiality. The firm should seek guidance and may need to apply to the court if there is a dispute. The firm should not destroy the file. The principal should document the conflict and the steps taken. The firm should also consider whether it must cease acting for both spouses in any ongoing matter. The safest course is to decline the new retainer, preserve the file, and advise the wife to obtain independent advice, while ensuring the husband's information is protected.