Trust Account Shortfall at a Property Management Firm
Broker Sal runs a property management and sales brokerage in Tucson. On May 1 the firm's property management trust account shows a $48,200 ledger balance for 60 tenant deposits and owner reserves. The bank statement shows $45,900. Sal's bookkeeper explains that $2,300 was used on April 27 to pay the firm's office rent because the operating account was overdrawn, and that she intended to repay it from June management fees. Separately, Sal's sales division received a $10,000 earnest money check on April 29 for a listing; the check was deposited into the property management trust account on May 2 because the escrow company had not yet opened the file. The firm's records are kept on a spreadsheet that has not been reconciled since March, and there is no separate ledger for the earnest money.
1. Identify each violation and the correct handling of the $2,300 and the $10,000.
Read the worked answer
Two distinct problems exist. First, using trust funds for the firm's office rent is conversion: broker funds may not be commingled with, or borrowed from, trust funds, even with an intent to repay. The $2,300 must be restored immediately from the operating account, and the shortfall must be documented and reported to the designated broker. Second, the $10,000 earnest money belongs in a trust account but must be separately identified and tracked; depositing it into the property management account without a separate ledger commingles it with tenant deposits and owner reserves. The earnest money should be moved promptly to the escrow company or held in a properly identified trust account with its own ledger showing the buyer, the property, and the disbursement authority. The firm must also reconcile all trust accounts monthly, and the spreadsheet gap since March must be reconstructed from bank statements, ledgers, and receipts so that each beneficiary's balance is verifiable. A broker who cannot account for trust funds faces discipline regardless of intent.
2. What records must Sal produce if the Commissioner audits, and what are the consequences of the unreconciled spreadsheet?
Read the worked answer
Sal must produce, for each trust account, a monthly reconciliation of the bank statement balance to the sum of all beneficiary ledgers, individual ledgers for each tenant, owner, and transaction, deposit and disbursement records, cancelled checks or bank images, and a journal or check register. The records must be retained for the period required by rule and must be available for inspection. An unreconciled account since March means Sal cannot demonstrate that trust funds are intact, which is itself a violation and may support an inference of misappropriation. The Commissioner may issue a citation, require education, impose a civil penalty, suspend or revoke the license, and require an accounting. Because tenant security deposits and owner funds are involved, Sal may also face civil liability to tenants and owners, and the firm's errors-and-omissions coverage may exclude intentional conversion. The practical fix is a forensic reconstruction, immediate restoration of the $2,300, segregation of the earnest money, and written policies assigning reconciliation to a person who does not handle disbursements.
3. What supervisory and bookkeeping controls should Sal adopt going forward?
Read the worked answer
Sal should separate duties: the person who writes checks should not be the person who reconciles the bank statement, and the designated broker should review and sign the monthly reconciliation. All trust disbursements should require supporting documentation and a second approval above a set threshold. The firm should maintain a chart of accounts distinguishing trust from operating funds, with separate ledgers for property management, sales escrow, and security deposits, and should never use trust funds for operating expenses. Monthly three-way reconciliation should compare the bank balance, the book balance, and the sum of beneficiary ledgers, with variances investigated and documented. The firm should adopt written procedures for earnest money handling, including timely deposit and delivery to escrow, and should train staff on the prohibition against commingling and conversion. Sal should also calendar record-retention deadlines and conduct periodic internal audits or hire an outside bookkeeper. These controls protect tenants and clients and give the broker evidence of supervision if the Commissioner later questions the account.