The Man Who Cannot Feel the Good News
A 45-year-old man is brought by his wife. For 7 weeks he has slept 3 hours, stopped eating, and sat staring at the wall. He says he is 'already dead inside' and that his family 'would be better off.' He has a plan to take his remaining tablets and has chosen a day when his wife is at her sister's. He has no history of mania, no psychotic symptoms, and no substance use. He scores 28 on the Beck Depression Inventory. His wife says he was 'completely normal' until 7 weeks ago, and that his father died by suicide at 52. He is currently on no medication.
1. Assess his risk and state what must happen before any psychological therapy begins.
Read the worked answer
Risk is high and immediate. The combination of a specific plan, a chosen method (tablets), a chosen time when he will be alone, expressed worthlessness ('already dead inside'), hopelessness, severe sleep and appetite loss, and a first-degree family history of suicide constitutes a high-risk picture. The BDI score of 28 is in the severe range and corroborates the clinical impression. The absence of psychosis and mania does not lower the risk; the planning does the opposite.
What must happen first.
- Do not leave him alone and do not send him home to 'think about it.' Arrange urgent same-day psychiatric assessment, and if he cannot be kept safe in the community, arrange emergency admission under the relevant mental health legislation.
- Means restriction. Ask the wife directly about the tablets and remove or secure them, along with any other means, before he leaves the building. This is one of the few interventions with strong evidence for reducing suicide.
- Safety plan with named contacts, crisis numbers, and a written agreement about what he will do if the urge intensifies - recognising that a no-harm contract alone is not a substitute for supervision.
- Physical workup. 7 weeks of near-total anorexia and 3 hours' sleep warrant baseline bloods, thyroid function, and a review of any medical cause; weight loss should be quantified.
- Inform the wife (with his consent where possible, but safety overrides secrecy) about warning signs and the plan.
Why therapy waits. Psychological therapy for depression is appropriate and effective, but it is not the first move in an acutely suicidal, severely symptomatic patient. Therapy requires a baseline of safety, sleep, and some capacity to engage. The sequence is: secure safety, treat the acute episode (medication and/or admission), then begin structured psychotherapy once risk is contained.
2. His wife asks whether his father's suicide means he is 'destined' to do the same, and whether he will need medication 'forever.' Answer both, accurately and without false reassurance.
Read the worked answer
On the family history. A father's suicide at 52 is a genuine risk factor - family history roughly doubles to triples risk in epidemiological terms - but it is a risk factor, not a destiny. Risk is probabilistic and modifiable. It is also confounded: the same family may carry unmeasured burdens (early loss, financial strain, untreated illness), and his father's death may have occurred in a different context. What the history should change is vigilance, not fatalism: earlier help-seeking, a standing safety plan, and prompt treatment of future episodes. It does not mean he will die the same way.
On medication 'forever.' Not usually. Standard guidance is that a first episode is treated for roughly 6-12 months after remission, then reviewed. Continuation is extended when there are risk factors for recurrence - multiple episodes, severe episodes, residual symptoms, or strong family history - sometimes for 2 years or longer, and long-term maintenance is reserved for those with recurrent illness. The decision is made on his course, not on a rule.
Honest framing. Say that medication is likely to be part of the next phase, that it takes several weeks to work, and that side effects are manageable and should be reported rather than endured silently. Pair it with psychotherapy, sleep restoration, and the safety plan. Avoid both extremes: do not promise he will be 'fine in a month,' and do not imply lifelong dependence. Frame it as a treatable episode with a monitored plan, and schedule a review point so the 'forever' question is revisited with evidence.