Dividend Withholding Tax on a Cross-Border Distribution
Deltawerf Holding BV is a Dutch resident company. It owns 100% of Deltawerf Deutschland GmbH, a German resident subsidiary. Deltawerf Deutschland pays a dividend of €2,000,000 to Deltawerf Holding BV. Germany levies a 26.375% withholding tax, of which €1,000,000 is withheld. The Netherlands and Germany have a tax treaty that reduces the withholding tax to 5% for qualifying parent companies. Deltawerf Holding BV holds more than 10% and has held the shares for four years. Deltawerf Holding BV also has a Dutch permanent establishment in Rotterdam with taxable profit of €3,000,000 before the dividend. The Dutch corporate income tax rate is 25.8%. The company asks you how the dividend and the foreign withholding tax should be treated in the Dutch corporate income tax return.
1. Explain the Dutch participation exemption and whether the German dividend is exempt in the Netherlands.
Read the worked answer
Under the Dutch participation exemption (deelnemingsvrijstelling, Article 13 of the Corporate Income Tax Act 1969), dividends received from a qualifying subsidiary are exempt from Dutch corporate income tax, provided the parent holds at least 5% of the nominal paid-up capital and the participation is not held as a portfolio investment. Deltawerf Holding BV holds 100%, so the 5% threshold is met. The participation must also not be a low-taxed portfolio investment. A 100% operating subsidiary in Germany is not a portfolio investment, so the exemption applies. The €2,000,000 dividend is therefore exempt from Dutch corporate income tax. The taxable profit of €3,000,000 from the Rotterdam permanent establishment is taxed at 25.8%, giving €774,000. The dividend itself is not added to the taxable base. Because the dividend is exempt, foreign withholding tax is generally not creditable against Dutch corporate income tax for the exempt dividend; the participation exemption operates as an exemption with no credit. The company should report the dividend as exempt income and not claim a foreign tax credit for the German withholding tax, unless a specific rule allows otherwise.
2. The company asks whether it can claim relief for the €1,000,000 German withholding tax. Advise on the options and the treaty position.
Read the worked answer
The treaty between the Netherlands and Germany reduces the withholding tax to 5% for qualifying parent companies, so the correct withholding tax is €2,000,000 × 5% = €100,000. The excess €900,000 withheld above the treaty rate can be reclaimed from the German tax authorities under the treaty's refund procedure. The company should file a refund claim with the German Bundeszentralamt für Steuern, supported by a residence certificate and evidence of the 10% holding and holding period. Because the dividend is exempt under the Dutch participation exemption, the Netherlands will not grant a foreign tax credit for the remaining €100,000. The participation exemption is an exemption system, so the withholding tax is a final cost unless the treaty or EU law provides relief. Under the EU Parent-Subsidiary Directive, intra-EU dividends between qualifying companies should be exempt from withholding tax, so the company may argue that no withholding tax should apply at all if the directive conditions are met. The practical advice is to claim the treaty refund and, if applicable, invoke the directive. Document the holding period, the ownership percentage, and the refund correspondence.