A Minor Requesting Treatment Without a Parent Present
A 16-year-old girl attends alone requesting composite veneers on her upper incisors because she dislikes their colour and a small chip. She is accompanied by a 19-year-old friend. She says her parents are divorced, her mother would refuse, and she does not want her father told. She is articulate, understands the procedure, and can pay. She has no medical history and no dental anxiety. The clinic is in Bahrain and follows local health regulation. There is a small fracture on the mesial corner of the upper right central incisor with no pulpal involvement. She asks you to keep the appointment confidential.
1. Can you treat her, and how do consent and confidentiality apply?
Read the worked answer
Consent for a minor is governed by local law and capacity, not simply by age. In Bahrain, a 16-year-old is generally still a minor for healthcare consent, so treatment usually requires consent from a parent or legal guardian, even if she understands the procedure. Her request for confidentiality must be balanced against the duty to involve a guardian for consent. I would explain that I cannot keep the consultation secret from her guardian, but I can discuss her concerns sensitively and involve her in decisions. The 19-year-old friend cannot consent for her. I would ask which parent holds legal authority and contact that parent with her knowledge, or advise her to bring the appropriate guardian. I would not proceed with elective veneers without valid consent, and I would document the discussion and her competence assessment.
2. What clinical and ethical approach would you take to the chipped incisor and her aesthetic concerns?
Read the worked answer
The chip is small and does not involve the pulp, so a conservative repair with composite is appropriate rather than veneers, which would remove sound enamel in a patient whose dentition is still maturing. I would explain the risks of irreversible tooth reduction at her age and offer a minimally invasive composite restoration to restore the corner and improve appearance. I would explore her aesthetic concerns and consider that her dislike of colour may reflect normal variation or unmet expectations; a discussion about realistic outcomes and possible whitening later is appropriate. Ethically, I should act in her best interests, avoid overtreatment, and not let her ability to pay drive the decision. Once valid guardian consent is obtained, I would treat conservatively and review.