Insurance Preauthorization and Treatment Sequencing for a Crown
A 60-year-old patient needs a crown on tooth 30 and a core buildup. The office submits a preauthorization to the insurance carrier, which returns a denial stating that the crown is not covered because the tooth has insufficient remaining tooth structure and the buildup is considered part of the crown. The patient's policy has a $1,500 annual maximum, and $1,200 has already been used this year. The patient is scheduled for the crown in two weeks and has already paid a $300 deposit. The dentist believes the crown is necessary and documents that the tooth has a fractured cusp. The patient asks whether the crown can be done anyway and whether the insurance will pay.
1. Evaluate the denial and recommend the next steps for the office and the patient.
Read the worked answer
The denial cites insufficient tooth structure and bundling of the buildup, which are common reasons for crown denials. The office should review the policy's criteria and the dentist's documentation. If the documentation supports medical necessity, the office should file an appeal with the narrative, radiographs, and clinical findings, including the fractured cusp. The patient should be informed that the appeal may take time and that the crown can proceed with the patient's consent to pay if the appeal is denied. The annual maximum of $1,500 with $1,200 already used means only $300 remains, so even if approved, the patient's out-of-pocket cost will be significant. The office should provide a written estimate and obtain a signed financial agreement before treatment.
2. Explain how the annual maximum affects the patient's financial responsibility and how the office should communicate this.
Read the worked answer
The patient has $300 remaining on the annual maximum. If the crown is approved at the carrier's allowed amount, the insurance will pay up to $300, and the patient will be responsible for the remainder plus any deductible or coinsurance. The office should calculate the estimated insurance payment and the patient's portion and present it in writing. The patient should be told that the deposit will be applied to the total and that any balance is due at the time of service or according to the office's payment policy. The assistant should avoid guaranteeing insurance payment and should explain that the appeal outcome may change the estimate. The patient should sign an acknowledgement of the estimate and the financial policy.
3. What documentation should the office prepare for the appeal, and how should the patient be involved?
Read the worked answer
The appeal should include the dentist's narrative describing the fractured cusp, the radiographs, the clinical examination findings, and the rationale for the crown and buildup. The office should reference the policy's criteria and explain why the tooth meets them. The patient should be asked to sign a release for the office to share records with the carrier and should be kept informed of the appeal timeline. The office should document all communications with the carrier and the patient. If the appeal is denied, the patient should be offered the option to proceed with the crown as a self-pay service or to consider alternatives, with the risks and benefits explained.