Editing a Ministerial Speech Under Time Pressure
A junior English officer in a ministry is asked to edit a speech for a senior official to be delivered in 18 hours at a national youth forum. The draft is 1,400 words, written in dense bureaucratic English, and contains a factual claim that 'youth unemployment has halved since 2019' for which the officer can find no source. The official's office has said the speech must not exceed 12 minutes (roughly 1,300 spoken words at a measured pace) and must 'sound like the official'. The officer has never met the official and has only two prior speeches as style samples. The forum will be live-streamed and journalists will attend. The officer's supervisor is unreachable until morning.
1. Explain how the officer should handle the unsourced unemployment claim, weighing accuracy, loyalty, and the live-streamed setting.
Read the worked answer
The claim cannot be delivered as stated without a verifiable source, because a live-streamed national forum with journalists converts an error into a public record. The officer should first attempt to locate the figure in official statistics or ministry records. If found and correct, retain it with a precise attribution such as the year and source. If not found, do not silently delete it, since that risks the official being blindsided if questioned. Instead, flag it clearly to the office with a recommended replacement - either a hedged statement consistent with known data or a qualitative claim about progress. The officer's duty is to protect the official from avoidable error while respecting the official's authority to decide; the decision should be documented in writing so responsibility is shared and traceable.
2. Propose an editing strategy that meets the time limit, preserves the official's voice, and is robust to the officer's lack of direct contact with the speaker.
Read the worked answer
Cut first for structure, then for register. Identify the three or four core messages and remove repetition and throat-clearing, targeting about 1,150 words to leave breathing room for pauses and ad-libbing within 12 minutes.
For voice, extract recurring patterns from the two sample speeches - sentence length, favoured connectives, degree of formality, use of personal anecdote - and edit toward those patterns rather than imposing the officer's own style. Mark any line where confidence is low with a note for the official to adjust.
Deliver a clean version plus a short cover note listing the substantive changes, the flagged claim, and two optional passages the official may cut if running long. This gives the speaker control, respects the deadline, and acknowledges the officer's limited knowledge of the speaker's preferences.