Hiring Surge at Larkspur Home Care
Larkspur Home Care provides in-home support to 900 clients with 410 caregivers across three regions. Annual turnover among caregivers is 46%, and the average cost to recruit and train a replacement is estimated at $3,200. Exit interviews cite unpredictable schedules and thin supervision. The operations director wants to hire 60 new caregivers immediately to cover a waiting list of 140 clients. The HR director argues that filling the pipeline without fixing retention will simply increase churn. The CEO has asked for a plan that addresses both the waiting list and the turnover, within a hiring budget of $250,000 for the next year.
1. Estimate the annual cost of turnover and assess whether the proposed 60 hires are the right response.
Read the worked answer
At 46% turnover on 410 caregivers, roughly 189 people leave each year. At $3,200 per replacement, that is about $605K annually in recruitment and training alone - more than double the $250K hiring budget, before counting lost productivity and client disruption.
Hiring 60 caregivers at $3,200 each would cost about $192K, which fits the budget but does not address the cause. If turnover stays at 46%, a large share of those new hires will leave within a year, so the waiting list may shrink briefly and then rebound. The analysis should compare the cost of each hire against the expected tenure: a hire who stays two years is far cheaper per client served than one who leaves in six months. The recommendation should split the budget between pipeline (recruitment) and retention (scheduling stability, supervisory contact), because retention improvements lower the effective cost per caregiver.
2. Recommend specific retention interventions and explain how to measure whether they work.
Read the worked answer
Target the two stated causes directly:
- Schedule predictability. Move toward published schedules with a fixed window and offer guaranteed hours to caregivers who commit to availability. Unpredictable hours are a leading driver of home-care attrition, and guaranteed hours also improve client continuity.
- Supervision. Increase the ratio of supervisors to caregivers and require regular check-ins. Thin supervision leaves new hires without support in a demanding, isolated job.
- Onboarding and peer support. Pair new caregivers with experienced mentors for the first 90 days, when most early exits occur.
Measurement. Track 90-day and 12-month retention separately, cost per retained caregiver, and client continuity (same caregiver over time). Compare regions or pilot cohorts before and after the change so the effect is not confused with seasonal variation. Report turnover cost as a KPI alongside headcount so the budget conversation reflects the full picture.