Choosing a Distribution Channel for Coconut Oil
A small producer on Eleuthera makes cold-pressed coconut oil in batches of 400 bottles a month. Each bottle costs B$4.50 to produce and sells to a wholesaler for B$7.00. The producer has two options. Option A: sell all output to a Nassau wholesaler who distributes to 30 small food stores; the wholesaler pays within 30 days but takes the entire batch, and the producer has no marketing costs. Option B: sell directly to consumers at farmers' markets and online at B$12.00 a bottle, but only 250 bottles a month can be sold this way, each sale carries B$1.50 in packaging and delivery, and the producer must spend B$300 a month on a market stall. The producer has B$2,000 of working capital and cannot borrow.
1. Calculate the monthly profit under each option and recommend one, considering both profit and risk.
Read the worked answer
Option A (wholesaler). Revenue = 400 × B$7.00 = B$2,800. Cost of goods = 400 × B$4.50 = B$1,800. Profit = B$1,000 per month.
Option B (direct). Revenue = 250 × B$12.00 = B$3,000. Production cost = 250 × B$4.50 = B$1,125. Selling costs = 250 × B$1.50 = B$375, plus B$300 stall = B$675. Profit = 3,000 − 1,125 − 675 = B$1,200 per month.
Direct selling earns B$200 more, but note that 150 bottles (400 − 250) are unsold unless they can also go to the wholesaler; if they cannot, B$675 of production is wasted and Option B actually loses money. Direct selling also requires the producer to hold stock, wait for retail sales, and absorb spoilage and bad debts. Option A converts the whole batch into a B$2,800 receivable within 30 days, which suits B$2,000 of working capital better.
Recommendation. A hybrid: commit the surplus 150 bottles to the wholesaler and sell 250 directly. That uses all output, earns the higher retail margin on part of the batch, and keeps cash flowing. Pure Option B is only safe if demand can be grown beyond 250 bottles.
2. Explain how the length of the channel affects the final price a consumer pays and the producer's control over how the product is presented.
Read the worked answer
Effect on price. Each intermediary in the chain must cover its own costs and margin. A wholesaler buying at B$7.00 and selling to retailers at, say, B$9.00 adds B$2.00; a retailer adding a 40% mark-up on B$9.00 sells at B$12.60. The longer the chain, the more mark-ups are stacked, so the consumer pays more even though the producer receives less. A direct channel removes those mark-ups, which is why the producer can charge B$12.00 and still earn more per bottle.
Effect on control. In a long channel the producer surrenders presentation: shelf position, storage temperature and how the oil is described are decided by others. Coconut oil can degrade if stored warm, and the producer cannot enforce storage standards through a wholesaler. In a short channel the producer controls display, sampling and the story behind the product, building brand loyalty.
Trade-off. Short channels give higher margins and control but limited reach and higher selling costs per unit; long channels give reach and cash certainty at the cost of margin and control.