Nassau's Cruise Passenger Squeeze
A cruise line wants to bring a 6,000-passenger ship to Nassau every Sunday, adding to ships that already arrive on other days. On a typical Sunday the town already receives about 12,000 cruise visitors between 9 a.m. and 4 p.m. Most walk to the straw market, the Queen's Staircase and a few nearby shops; only about 15% take a paid tour. Vendors report good sales on busy days but complain that passengers haggle and buy little. Taxi drivers say the traffic on Bay Street is already slow, and residents avoid downtown on ship days. The port can handle the extra ship, but the pier area and the main street cannot be widened. The government is considering a limit on the number of ships per day and a small passenger fee to fund downtown improvements.
1. Using the figures, assess whether the extra ship would bring more benefit than cost to downtown Nassau.
Read the worked answer
The extra ship adds 6,000 people to about 12,000, a 50% increase in a seven-hour window. If the 15% tour rate holds, that is only about 900 extra tour customers, so most of the new arrivals would crowd the same few free or cheap sites: the straw market, the Queen's Staircase and Bay Street. Vendors gain more potential customers, but if passengers mainly browse and haggle, extra numbers may add litter, congestion and pressure on toilets and pavements without much extra spending. Taxi drivers gain fares only from the minority who take tours. Residents lose access to their own downtown, which is a cost that does not appear in the cruise line's accounts. The benefits are concentrated in a few businesses; the costs fall on residents and on the public purse for cleaning and policing. A fair judgement is that the ship adds some income but the crowding cost rises faster than the benefit, so a daily cap and a fee are reasonable.
2. Explain why a passenger fee might be fairer than simply banning the extra ship.
Read the worked answer
A ban protects residents but throws away all the income, including the income that could pay for improvements. A fee charges the people who create the crowding and who benefit from the port, so the cost falls on the cruise line and its passengers rather than on Bahamian taxpayers. If the fee is set per passenger, the cruise line has an incentive to bring fewer, higher-spending visitors or to spread arrivals across the week. The money can fund wider pavements, toilets, waste collection and vendor training, which raises the quality of the visit and may encourage passengers to spend more. The fee must be small enough not to drive ships to another port, and it should be combined with a daily ship cap so that the fee does not simply become a licence to overcrowd. A judgement should note that fees are regressive for crew and low-income passengers unless the cruise line absorbs them.
3. Design a short fieldwork study to measure the economic impact of cruise visitors on one street in downtown Nassau.
Read the worked answer
Choose one 200 m stretch of Bay Street and count pedestrians at three points every 20 minutes from 9 a.m. to 4 p.m. on a ship day and on a no-ship day, using tally sheets and noting whether each person appears to be a cruise passenger (wristband, lanyard, ship card). Record the number of shops open and interview 15 shopkeepers about sales that day, using a short fixed questionnaire with sales bands rather than exact figures. Note litter counts and traffic speed at fixed times. Present results as a bar chart comparing ship and no-ship days. Limitations: it is hard to identify cruise passengers reliably, one day may not be typical, and shopkeepers may not know or may not reveal sales. The strength is the comparison day, which controls for weather and season better than a single survey.