Handling a Request to Exempt a Student from the Sacraments Unit
Your third-year RE class is beginning a unit on the sacraments, which includes a lesson where students prepare for and discuss the experience of receiving a sacrament, and a school Mass is scheduled at the end of the unit. A parent writes to say that their child, who is not baptised and whose family are not religious, should be exempted from the entire unit because it is 'religious instruction' and conflicts with their family's beliefs. The student has told you privately that they do not mind learning about the sacraments but feel awkward at the Mass and do not want to be the only one not receiving communion. The school's RE programme is designed to be inclusive of all students and is not confessional, but the school is a Catholic school with a Catholic ethos. The principal asks you to advise on the request.
1. Analyse the request and advise the principal on whether the student should be exempted from the unit.
Read the worked answer
The request should be analysed in two parts, because it conflates two different things: the classroom unit and the school Mass. The classroom unit is part of the school's RE programme, which is designed to be inclusive and educational rather than confessional. It teaches students about the sacraments as part of religious literacy and invites them to understand a central dimension of Catholic life. Exempting a student from the whole unit would deny them access to the curriculum and would not be justified simply because the family is non-religious, since the unit does not require belief or participation in a sacrament. The appropriate response is to reassure the parent about the nature of the unit, share the materials, and explain that the student will be learning about the sacraments, not being formed in them.
The Mass is different. Attendance at a school Mass is a participation in a religious act, and a student who is not baptised may reasonably feel excluded, particularly around communion. The student's own concern is not the curriculum but the awkwardness of being visibly different. The advice to the principal should therefore be: do not exempt the student from the unit, but offer a meaningful alternative for the Mass, such as a role in the liturgy of the word, a reading, or participation in the preparation, and allow the student to choose. If the family still objects to the Mass, an alternative supervised activity should be offered rather than forced participation. The student's own views should be taken seriously and should carry weight, since the student has said they do not mind the unit.
2. Explain how you would respond to the parent and to the student, and why you would respond in those ways.
Read the worked answer
To the parent I would write a respectful, clear letter that begins by thanking them for raising the concern and by acknowledging their family's position. I would explain what the unit actually involves, distinguishing learning about the sacraments from receiving them, and I would offer to share the scheme of work and lesson materials. I would make clear that the school does not require the student to believe or to participate in a sacrament, and that the student will be assessed on understanding, not on faith. I would also explain the arrangements for the Mass, including the alternative role or activity, and invite the parent to discuss this further. I would not concede exemption from the unit, but I would make clear that the student's comfort at the Mass is being taken seriously.
To the student I would speak privately and thank them for being honest. I would reassure them that they are not required to receive communion and that many people attend Mass without receiving. I would offer a concrete role, such as carrying a reading or helping with the procession, so that they are participating rather than standing out as an exception, and I would let them choose whether to take it. I would explain what will happen at the Mass so there are no surprises. The reasoning is that the parent's concern is best addressed through transparency and reassurance rather than concession, while the student's concern is best addressed through practical inclusion and choice. Treating the student as a partner in the decision respects their growing autonomy and avoids making them a battleground between home and school.
3. Explain how you would protect the student's wellbeing and the school's ethos in the lessons leading up to the Mass.
Read the worked answer
In the lessons I would make inclusion explicit from the start. I would begin the unit by explaining that the class includes people of different beliefs and none, and that the aim is to understand the sacraments, not to require anyone to accept them. I would set ground rules that include the right to pass and the right not to disclose personal beliefs. When discussing the experience of receiving a sacrament, I would use case studies and guest perspectives rather than asking students to share their own sacramental status, so that no student is put on the spot. I would ensure that the language of the lessons does not assume that everyone is baptised, for example by referring to 'Catholics' rather than 'we' when describing sacramental practice.
For the Mass, I would prepare the whole class in advance, explaining what will happen, what communion means for Catholics, and that not receiving is a normal and respected choice. I would give the student a role and a choice, and I would check in privately before and after. I would also brief the special needs assistant or any supervising staff so that no one inadvertently draws attention to the student. In this way the school's ethos is respected because the Mass is celebrated properly and the unit is taught faithfully, while the student's wellbeing is protected because they are included on their own terms. If the parent remains opposed to the Mass, I would offer the alternative activity and record the arrangement, so that the student is not placed in an impossible position between home and school.