The Client Account Shortfall and the Undertaking
A sole practitioner, Mr Bhatt, acts for a buyer, Chen, in a £640,000 purchase. On a Friday afternoon, Mr Bhatt's client account shows £612,000 held for Chen, but the completion statement requires £640,000 by 3pm. Mr Bhatt's office manager reports that £30,000 belonging to another client, Mrs Okafor, was mistakenly transferred into Chen's ledger two weeks earlier and has not been corrected. Mr Bhatt also holds a signed undertaking from the seller's solicitor to redeem the seller's mortgage and to send the discharge within 10 days of completion. The lender has released funds to Mr Bhatt's client account, but the funds are £28,000 short because a bank transfer was delayed. Mr Bhatt asks whether he can use Mrs Okafor's £30,000 temporarily and replace it on Monday.
1. Advise Mr Bhatt on the client account shortfall and the use of Mrs Okafor's funds.
Read the worked answer
Mr Bhatt must not use Mrs Okafor's £30,000 to complete Chen's purchase. Client money is held on trust for the client to whom it belongs. Using one client's money for another client's transaction is a breach of trust and a serious breach of the SRA Accounts Rules. It may also amount to a criminal offence (for example, theft or fraud) and must be reported.
The mistaken transfer. The £30,000 was transferred to Chen's ledger in error. Mr Bhatt must correct the ledger immediately, restore the funds to Mrs Okafor's ledger, and inform both clients. He should not wait until Monday. He should also investigate how the error occurred and consider whether a suspicious activity report is needed.
The shortfall. The £28,000 shortfall arises from a delayed bank transfer. Mr Bhatt should:
- Contact the bank to trace and expedite the transfer.
- Contact the lender and the seller's solicitor to explain the delay and agree a short extension.
- Consider using his own funds (office account) to bridge the gap, provided this is properly recorded and does not breach the rules.
- Not complete until the funds are in place, unless the seller agrees to a later completion and the lender consents.
Undertaking. The undertaking from the seller's solicitor is separate. Mr Bhatt should ensure the seller's solicitor complies with it. If the seller's mortgage is not redeemed, the buyer may take subject to the charge. Mr Bhatt should monitor the 10-day period and, if necessary, enforce the undertaking.
Reporting. Mr Bhatt should consider his obligations under the SRA Accounts Rules and the money laundering regulations. He should notify his insurer and, if there is a serious breach, the SRA. He should keep a written record of the error and the steps taken.
2. Explain the risks to Chen and the steps Mr Bhatt should take before and after completion.
Read the worked answer
Risks to Chen.
Delay. If completion is delayed, Chen may be in breach of contract and liable for penalty interest or damages. The seller may rescind.
Mortgage not redeemed. If the seller's mortgage is not discharged, Chen may take the property subject to the charge. The undertaking is only as good as the seller's solicitor's ability to comply.
Client account breach. If Mr Bhatt uses Mrs Okafor's money, Chen's funds may be at risk and the transaction may be tainted. Chen could face a claim or regulatory investigation.
Lender requirements. The lender may withdraw the offer if completion is not on time.
Before completion. Mr Bhatt should:
- correct the ledger and restore Mrs Okafor's funds;
- trace the delayed transfer and obtain confirmation of the expected arrival time;
- obtain the lender's written consent to any delay;
- agree a revised completion time with the seller's solicitor;
- confirm the seller's solicitor's undertaking is still valid and that the discharge will be provided;
- check that all completion documents are in order.
After completion. Mr Bhatt should:
- send the completion statement and transfer to the lender;
- register the buyer's title and the lender's charge at HRL;
- pay stamp duty land tax within 14 days;
- monitor the seller's solicitor's compliance with the undertaking and, if not complied with, enforce it;
- keep records of the client account correction and report any breach.
Conclusion. Mr Bhatt must not use Mrs Okafor's funds. He should resolve the shortfall through the bank, his own funds or a agreed extension, and protect Chen's position by written advice and careful documentation.