The Reverse Mortgage Question at Retirement
Robert and Louise, both 71, own a $700,000 home with no mortgage. Their income is $52,000 from pensions and government benefits. They have $30,000 in savings and $14,000 in credit-card debt. Louise has a chronic condition requiring $900 per month in uninsured medication. They want to stay in the home but are short about $1,200 per month. A reverse mortgage representative has offered a lump sum of $150,000, which they would use to clear the card and cover the shortfall. They ask their broker, who normally handles purchases, for an opinion.
1. What factors should the broker weigh before endorsing a reverse mortgage for this couple?
Read the worked answer
The broker should treat this as a suitability question, not a product sale. Key factors:
Cost structure. Reverse mortgages carry setup fees, closing costs, and interest that compounds on the outstanding balance. On a $150,000 draw, the balance grows over time, eroding equity. The broker should obtain a written estimate of the balance in 10 and 15 years at current rates.
Alternatives. A home equity line of credit may be cheaper for a modest monthly shortfall, though it requires servicing interest. Downsizing to a smaller home could free equity without compounding debt. A secured line used only for the medication shortfall may be more efficient than a $150,000 lump sum.
Sustainability. The $1,200 monthly shortfall is driven partly by the $900 medication cost, which may be partially covered by public programs or private insurance. The broker should ask whether that cost is permanent or reducible.
Estate impact. Robert and Louise should understand how the growing balance affects what heirs receive and whether the home remains sellable to repay the loan.
2. The representative pressures them: "Rates are rising, sign this week." How should the broker advise, and what does the couple need to understand about the lump sum?
Read the worked answer
The broker should neutralize the urgency. Rate movements are not a reason to sign a complex lifelong product within a week. The couple should be told they can take time, seek independent legal advice, and compare at least one alternative.
On the lump sum specifically, they need to understand:
- Drawing $150,000 when they need roughly $14,400 per year for the shortfall plus $14,000 to clear the card means most of the money sits idle while interest accrues on the full amount. A smaller draw or a line-of-credit structure may cost far less.
- Reverse mortgage balances typically do not require monthly payments, so the debt compounds. They should see the projected balance, not just the initial advance.
- The home must remain their principal residence, and property taxes and insurance must still be paid; failure to do so can trigger default.
The broker's advice should be documented: the alternatives presented, the couple's stated priorities, and their decision. If the broker is not licensed for this product, the correct step is to refer them to a qualified professional while still flagging the urgency tactic and the idle-funds problem.