The Deposit That Was Never Deposited
A manager oversees trust accounts for a small property management firm. On the first of the month, a tenant paid a $1,200 security deposit by e-transfer. The manager deposited it into the firm's general operating account because the trust account transfer had not yet cleared, intending to move it the next day. Two weeks later the deposit is still in the operating account, and the manager used $400 of it to cover a plumbing invoice for that same property because the owner's repair funds had not arrived. The firm's bookkeeper has not reconciled the trust account in three months. The owner now asks for a statement of deposits held for the property. The tenant has given proper notice to end the tenancy in 30 days.
1. Identify each trust accounting failure in this scenario and explain why each matters.
Read the worked answer
There are at least four failures. First, the security deposit was placed in the general operating account. Tenant deposits are trust funds and must be deposited into the trust account promptly, not held in operating funds. Second, the deposit was commingled with the firm's own money, which destroys the ability to show that tenant funds are intact. Third, $400 of the deposit was used for the owner's repair expense. Trust money may only be disbursed for the purpose for which it was entrusted; using a tenant's deposit to fund a landlord expense is a misappropriation even if the owner eventually repays it. Fourth, the trust account was not reconciled monthly. Regular reconciliation is what detects shortages and errors, and a three-month gap means the firm cannot demonstrate the funds are balanced. Each failure is a record-keeping and fiduciary breach, and together they create real risk that the tenant's deposit will not be repayable on time.
2. The tenancy ends and the tenant is owed the deposit back. What must the manager do, and what should happen to the $400?
Read the worked answer
The manager must return the deposit, less only lawful deductions supported by the required documentation, within the time required after the end of the tenancy. Because the $400 was improperly spent, the firm must restore it from its own operating funds immediately; the trust account must be made whole before any return is calculated. The manager should prepare a written accounting showing the deposit received, any permitted deductions with supporting invoices or claims, and the balance owing, and deliver it with the refund. The $400 plumbing cost belongs to the owner, and the firm should invoice the owner separately rather than netting it against tenant money. The manager should also report the reconciliation gap to the broker or managing broker, initiate a full reconciliation, and correct the process so deposits go directly to trust and owner expenses are never paid from tenant funds.