Client Suitability Under a Time Squeeze
A 61-year-old client, recently widowed, holds $540,000 in an IRA and $90,000 in a taxable account. Her stated goal is to draw $2,800 per month starting in 14 months to supplement Social Security. She has no emergency fund, a 22-year mortgage balance, and a moderate risk tolerance she describes as "not losing sleep, but I can't afford a big drop." At a meeting, her adult son urges her to move the entire IRA into a single technology sector fund that returned 38% last year. The client says, "If my son thinks it's a good idea, maybe we should just do it." She asks you to submit the transfer today because the fund's price may rise. Your firm's new-account and suitability documentation is not yet complete.
1. Identify the suitability and capacity concerns you must resolve before acting on the requested transfer, and explain how each affects your recommendation.
Read the worked answer
The first issue is capacity and time horizon. The client needs $2,800 per month beginning in 14 months, which is about $33,600 per year. A single sector fund can fall 40% or more in a year, so the withdrawal plan would be exposed to sequencing risk right at the start. Her stated risk tolerance is moderate, and the son's suggestion is not her own independent judgment; she is deferring to him. That raises a potential undue-influence concern, so you should document a private conversation confirming her objectives and risk tolerance.
The second issue is liquidity. She has no emergency fund and a mortgage, so all near-term cash needs would be met by selling investments, possibly at a loss. Before any transfer, you need to determine whether a cash reserve of six to twelve months of expenses can be carved out.
The third issue is documentation and concentration. Firm policy requires completed new-account paperwork and a suitability record before the transfer. A 100% allocation to one sector also creates concentration risk that conflicts with her moderate tolerance. The recommendation should be to decline the same-day transfer, complete the profile, and propose a diversified allocation with a short-term bond or cash sleeve sized to cover the first two to three years of withdrawals.
2. The son pushes back, saying the client is an adult and can make her own decisions. How should you handle the family dynamic while meeting your obligations?
Read the worked answer
You should acknowledge the son's role without letting him drive the recommendation. Explain that your duty runs to the client, and that you need to hear her objectives directly. Ask the son to step out briefly so you can confirm privately what she wants, whether she feels pressured, and whether she understands the concentration risk. Document that conversation.
If she still wants the sector fund after a full explanation, you can discuss a limited allocation, for example 5% to 10% of the IRA, rather than the full balance. That respects her autonomy while managing concentration. Make clear in writing that the fund is volatile, that the withdrawal plan could force sales during a decline, and that the rest of the portfolio must carry the income need. If the request is inconsistent with the documented profile, escalate to your supervisor or compliance rather than simply executing it.