Refusal of a Blood Transfusion in a Patient With Postpartum Hemorrhage
A 29-year-old woman, 6 hours postpartum after a spontaneous vaginal delivery, is bleeding heavily. Estimated blood loss is now 1,400 mL and ongoing. She is pale, HR 124, BP 88/52, RR 24, and reports feeling dizzy. She has an advance directive stating she is a Jehovah's Witness and refuses all blood products, including red cells, platelets, and plasma. Her hemoglobin is 6.2 g/dL. She is alert and oriented, answers questions appropriately, and repeats clearly that she understands she could die without transfusion. Her partner is at the bedside urging her to accept blood, and the obstetrician says, "Just give it, she's not thinking straight." The charge nurse asks the bedside nurse to handle the situation.
1. Evaluate the patient's decision-making capacity and describe how the nurse should respond to the obstetrician's directive.
Read the worked answer
The nurse should not accept the premise that the patient is incoherent. Capacity requires that the patient understand the information, appreciate the consequences, reason about options, and communicate a consistent choice. This patient is alert, oriented, answers appropriately, and clearly restates that she understands transfusion refusal could be fatal, which supports capacity even though she is hypotensive and anemic. Capacity is decision-specific, so the nurse should document the conversation, the patient's exact words, and that alternatives were offered. The nurse should then respond to the obstetrician respectfully but firmly: administer blood over the patient's clear refusal would be battery, and a physician's disagreement does not override a capacitated adult's decision. The nurse should ask the provider to document the discussion, request an ethics consult or a second clinician to confirm capacity if there is genuine doubt, and involve the charge nurse and risk management. The partner's pressure is understandable but does not change the patient's authority. The nurse's role is to protect autonomy while continuing aggressive non-transfusion resuscitation.
2. Describe the non-blood-product resuscitation measures the nurse should anticipate and prepare, and how each will be monitored.
Read the worked answer
Because transfusion is off the table, the nurse should focus on stopping the bleeding and maintaining perfusion. Anticipate uterotonics such as oxytocin, methylergonovine if not contraindicated, carboprost, and misoprostol per provider order; uterine massage and bimanual compression; and escalation to procedures such as balloon tamponade, uterine artery embolization, or surgery if bleeding continues. For volume and oxygen carrying capacity, anticipate crystalloid, and per order iron, erythropoietin, tranexamic acid, and possibly cell salvage if the institution and patient permit it, since some Jehovah's Witness patients accept certain fractions and the nurse must clarify what she personally accepts rather than assume. Monitor vital signs frequently, strict intake and output, mental status, skin color and temperature, and serial hemoglobin and coagulation studies. Watch for dilutional coagulopathy and for signs of shock. The nurse should also prepare for rapid escalation to the operating room and keep the patient and family informed at each step.
3. The partner pulls the nurse aside and says, "She's not herself, please just do something." Formulate the nurse's response and the communication plan with the team.
Read the worked answer
The nurse should acknowledge the partner's fear without agreeing to override the patient. A workable response: "I hear how scared you are, and we are doing everything possible that she has agreed to. She has told us clearly that she understands the risk and does not want blood, and I am not able to go against that. What I can do is keep you informed and make sure she is not alone." The nurse should offer to bring in an ethics consultant or chaplain, ask the patient directly whether she wants her partner present for the discussion, and avoid debating the patient's religion at the bedside. With the team, the nurse should request a documented capacity assessment, a clear plan for hemorrhage control, and a huddle so all staff know the refusal is documented and not to be circumvented. The nurse should also ensure the advance directive is on the chart and that the plan for deterioration, including comfort-focused goals if she worsens, is discussed with the patient while she can participate. Document the partner's concerns and the patient's responses.