Medical Emergency and Duty to Act
You are a security guard at a community centre. At 19:00, a staff member frantically tells you that a man (Ravi) has collapsed in the gymnasium. You arrive to find Ravi on the floor, unconscious, not breathing normally, and turning blue. There are about 20 people in the gym, some panicking. You have a first aid kit and an AED on the wall. You are certified in CPR and first aid, but you have never used an AED in a real emergency. Your phone is in your pocket. Another guard is on break and not reachable. The centre's emergency plan says: 'Call 911, provide first aid, and use AED if trained.' You are trained. You also know that as a security guard, you have a duty to act within the scope of your training and to not exceed it. You are not a paramedic.
1. What are your immediate priorities, and in what order?
Read the worked answer
Your immediate priorities follow the emergency response sequence: ensure scene safety, call for help, and provide care. First, ensure the scene is safe for you and Ravi; the gym is indoors, so likely safe, but check for hazards. Second, call 911 immediately, either yourself or direct a specific bystander to call and report back. Give clear information: location, Ravi's condition, and that he is unconscious and not breathing normally. Third, start CPR and use the AED as soon as possible. The AED is on the wall; you should send someone to get it while you begin chest compressions. You are trained, so you are authorized to use it. Do not hesitate because you have never used it in a real emergency; the AED provides voice prompts. Fourth, direct other staff to manage the crowd, keep the area clear, and meet EMS at the entrance. Your duty is to act within your training; you are not expected to perform advanced medical procedures. Continue CPR and AED use until EMS arrives or Ravi starts breathing. Document the incident afterward, including times and actions. Your actions should be reasonable and within your training, and you should not be deterred by fear of liability; good Samaritan laws and your training protect you if you act reasonably.
2. What if Ravi's friend, who is a nurse, offers to take over?
Read the worked answer
If a nurse offers to take over, you should accept the offer if they are willing and able to provide care. As a security guard, you are not the most qualified person if a medical professional is present. You should briefly confirm their identity and qualifications, then hand over care, but remain available to assist. You should continue to manage the scene: ensure someone has called 911, get the AED if not already there, keep the crowd back, and record the time and details. You should not simply walk away; you remain responsible for the overall scene until EMS arrives. If the nurse takes over, follow their directions for assistance, such as fetching the AED or performing CPR when relieved. Document that a nurse assisted and their name if possible. Your duty is to ensure the best care for Ravi, not to retain control. This is consistent with your training and the emergency plan. After the incident, write a report noting the handover and any actions taken. Your legal duty is to act reasonably, and allowing a more qualified person to help is reasonable.