I85PREP
⌘ K
NCA Professional Responsibility study materials
NCA Professional Responsibility study resources

NCA Professional Responsibility practice questions

One question at a time. Build your NCA Professional Responsibility understanding.

First 50 of 200 questions. Each one lists the choices, the correct answer, and an explanation. The checker at the top of this page saves progress in this browser when it is available.

Continue in the practice tool above to load more questions, 50 at a time.

Question 1Professional Responsibility

Under the NCA's professional responsibility expectations, which obligation applies to a candidate who learns that a fellow candidate has submitted fabricated work experience hours?

  1. Report the matter to the NCA so the integrity of the licensing process is protected Correct answer.
  2. Ignore the matter because each candidate's file is assessed independently by the NCA
  3. Wait until after licensing and then raise the issue only if the other candidate is hired
  4. Confront the other candidate privately and keep the matter confidential between the two of them

Explanation

Candidates owe a duty of candour and integrity to the regulator, and that duty extends to protecting the licensing process from fraudulent submissions. Fabricated experience hours undermine the reliability of the competence assessment, so a candidate who becomes aware of them is expected to bring the matter to the NCA rather than handle it informally.

Question 2Professional Responsibility

What is the primary purpose of the NCA's professional responsibility requirements for licensing candidates?

  1. To protect the public by ensuring licensees meet ethical and competence standards Correct answer.
  2. To replace provincial law society discipline processes entirely
  3. To increase the fees collected by the regulator from new entrants
  4. To standardise the marketing practices of law firms across Canada

Explanation

Professional responsibility requirements exist to safeguard the public interest by confirming that those admitted to practice are both competent and ethical. Public protection, not revenue or marketing uniformity, is the organising rationale for the regulator's expectations of candidates.

Question 3Professional Responsibility

A candidate is unsure whether a particular client communication would breach confidentiality. Which approach best reflects professional responsibility?

  1. Defer to whatever the opposing party's counsel considers acceptable
  2. Apply the least restrictive interpretation so information flows smoothly
  3. Err on the side of protecting confidentiality and seek guidance before disclosing Correct answer.
  4. Disclose freely because the client can always complain later

Explanation

Confidentiality is a foundational duty, and uncertainty should be resolved in favour of preserving the client's confidence pending proper guidance. Disclosing first and relying on later complaints inverts the duty and risks irreversible harm to the client.

Question 4Professional Responsibility

Which statement best describes a conflict of interest in the practice of law?

  1. A lawyer's duty to one client is compromised by a competing duty or personal interest Correct answer.
  2. Any situation where two clients pay different hourly rates
  3. A circumstance where a client changes lawyers midway through a matter
  4. A disagreement between a lawyer and a client about billing amounts

Explanation

A conflict of interest arises where a lawyer's loyalty or judgment on behalf of a client is, or may be, impaired by another duty, interest, or relationship. Differential fees, fee disputes, and changes of counsel are not conflicts in themselves.

Question 5Professional Responsibility

A lawyer discovers that a document produced by the opposing party was inadvertently disclosed and is clearly privileged. What is the professionally responsible course?

  1. Use the document strategically because the mistake was the other side's fault
  2. Notify opposing counsel promptly and refrain from using the document until the issue is resolved Correct answer.
  3. Destroy the document and say nothing to anyone about it
  4. Share the document with the client but not with the court

Explanation

Professional responsibility requires candour and fairness in dealings with opposing parties, and taking unfair advantage of an obvious mistake breaches that standard. Prompt notification allows the privilege issue to be resolved properly, and the document should not be exploited in the meantime.

Question 6Professional Responsibility

Which of the following best describes a lawyer's fiduciary duty to a client?

  1. An obligation to follow every instruction without any professional judgment
  2. A requirement to charge the lowest available fee in the market
  3. A duty to guarantee a favourable outcome in every matter
  4. An obligation to act with loyalty and in the client's best interests, above the lawyer's own Correct answer.

Explanation

The fiduciary relationship requires loyalty, good faith, and the subordination of the lawyer's personal interests to those of the client. It does not guarantee outcomes, mandate minimum fees, or eliminate the lawyer's professional judgment.

Question 7Professional Responsibility

A client asks a lawyer to advance a legal position that the lawyer believes has no reasonable basis. How should the lawyer respond?

  1. Advance the position but disclaim responsibility in writing to the court
  2. Advance the position anyway because the client is paying for the service
  3. Withdraw from the matter without telling the client why
  4. Decline to advance the position and explain the lack of a reasonable basis to the client Correct answer.

Explanation

Lawyers must not bring proceedings or advance positions that lack a reasonable basis, and they owe the client an explanation of that professional constraint. Advancing a baseless position harms the justice system and cannot be cured by a disclaimer.

Question 8Professional Responsibility

What does the duty of competence require of a lawyer taking on a new area of practice?

  1. Relying on the client to supply the missing legal expertise
  2. Attaining the necessary knowledge and skill, or associating with someone who has it, before acting Correct answer.
  3. Proceeding because enthusiasm can substitute for experience
  4. Accepting the matter and learning only from the client's feedback

Explanation

Competence requires the knowledge, skill, and diligence reasonably necessary for the matter, which may be met through study or association with a competent lawyer. Clients cannot be expected to supply legal expertise, and good intentions do not replace competence.

Question 9Professional Responsibility

A lawyer is asked to act for two co-accused whose defences are likely to diverge. What is the appropriate professional response?

  1. Accept both clients and let them sort out any disagreements between themselves later
  2. Decline the joint retainer or obtain informed consent only if the joint representation is genuinely viable Correct answer.
  3. Accept both clients but keep separate files without telling them
  4. Accept both clients and disclose each one's confidences to the other

Explanation

Joint representation of clients with potentially divergent interests creates a serious risk of conflicting loyalties and compromised confidences. The lawyer should decline unless the joint retainer is genuinely viable and all affected clients give informed consent.

Question 10Professional Responsibility

Which of the following is an example of conduct that would likely breach a lawyer's duty of honesty to a tribunal?

  1. Requesting an adjournment for a legitimate scheduling conflict
  2. Advising a client of the strengths and weaknesses of the case
  3. Correcting an error in a document before filing it
  4. Citing a case that counsel knows has been overruled without disclosing that fact Correct answer.

Explanation

Candour toward the tribunal requires disclosure of adverse authorities that are directly on point, including the fact that a cited case has been overruled. Correcting errors, giving candid advice, and legitimate adjournment requests are consistent with professional duties.

Question 11Professional Responsibility

A lawyer's trust account receives client funds. Which practice is required?

  1. Borrowing from the trust account with a promise to repay before month end
  2. Depositing client funds into the firm's general operating account for convenience
  3. Keeping client funds separate from the lawyer's own funds and maintaining accurate records Correct answer.
  4. Using one client's funds temporarily to cover another client's shortfall

Explanation

Trust funds must be held separately from the lawyer's own money and accounted for through accurate, contemporaneous records. Commingling, using one client's funds for another, and borrowing from trust are serious breaches of the fiduciary duty over client property.

Question 12Professional Responsibility

A lawyer realises mid-trial that she failed to disclose a relevant procedural step required by the rules of court. What should she do?

  1. Disclose the omission to the court promptly and take steps to remedy it Correct answer.
  2. Wait until the judgment and raise it on appeal if unfavourable
  3. Ask the client to decide whether to disclose the omission
  4. Remain silent and hope the omission goes unnoticed

Explanation

Candour toward the tribunal requires prompt disclosure of errors or omissions that could mislead the court, together with reasonable steps to correct them. Concealment, shifting the decision to the client, and waiting for appeal all compromise the integrity of the proceeding.

Question 13Professional Responsibility

Which statement best captures a lawyer's obligation when withdrawing from representation?

  1. Withdraw at any time without notice because the retainer is terminable at will
  2. Withdraw only on proper grounds and take reasonable steps to avoid prejudice to the client Correct answer.
  3. Withdraw without informing the court even when a matter is scheduled
  4. Withdraw only after the client has paid all outstanding fees in full

Explanation

Withdrawal must rest on proper grounds and must be managed so that the client is not left prejudiced, which typically includes reasonable notice and time to retain new counsel. Withdrawal is not conditioned on payment, and courts must be informed where proceedings are affected.

Question 14Professional Responsibility

A lawyer is offered a gift of substantial value by a client grateful for a successful outcome. What is the professionally appropriate approach?

  1. Accept the gift because gratitude gifts are always permissible
  2. Ask the client for a larger gift to reflect the result achieved
  3. Accept the gift and bill the client at the full rate as well
  4. Consider whether the gift could impair independence or appear to exploit the relationship, and decline if so Correct answer.

Explanation

Lawyers must avoid arrangements that could compromise independence or create the appearance of exploiting the fiduciary relationship. A substantial gift from a client warrants scrutiny and should be declined where it risks that perception.

Question 15Professional Responsibility

What does the duty of confidentiality generally prohibit a lawyer from doing?

  1. Declining to answer a question that would require disclosing client information
  2. Keeping client files secure in a locked cabinet
  3. Discussing the existence of the retainer with the client who retained the lawyer
  4. Revealing information learned in the professional relationship without proper authorisation Correct answer.

Explanation

Confidentiality prohibits disclosure of information acquired in the professional relationship absent authorisation or a recognised exception. Speaking with the client, securing files, and declining to answer are all consistent with the duty rather than breaches of it.

Question 16Professional Responsibility

A lawyer is asked to represent a client in a matter in which the lawyer has a personal financial stake. What should the lawyer do first?

  1. Proceed but conceal the personal stake from the client
  2. Identify the conflict and determine whether it can be managed or must be declined Correct answer.
  3. Proceed because personal interests are irrelevant to professional obligations
  4. Transfer the file to a junior lawyer without any disclosure

Explanation

A personal financial stake can impair the lawyer's judgment and must be identified and assessed before the retainer is accepted. Concealing the interest or silently reassigning the file does not satisfy the duty of loyalty and candour to the client.

Question 17Professional Responsibility

Which of the following best describes the role of informed consent in managing a conflict of interest?

  1. Consent cures every conflict regardless of how serious it is
  2. Consent is unnecessary because lawyers may decide conflicts themselves
  3. Consent must always be obtained from the opposing party
  4. The client's consent after full disclosure of the material risks may permit representation in some cases Correct answer.

Explanation

Informed consent, given after full and fair disclosure of the material risks, may allow a lawyer to act in certain conflict situations. Consent cannot cure every conflict, and the opposing party's consent is not the relevant consent.

Question 18Professional Responsibility

A lawyer learns from a client that the client intends to commit a serious crime causing imminent harm. Which statement reflects professional responsibility?

  1. The lawyer must personally intervene to physically stop the client
  2. The lawyer should publicise the client's plan widely on social media
  3. Confidentiality may be overridden where necessary to prevent serious imminent harm Correct answer.
  4. Confidentiality is absolute and permits no exception in any circumstance

Explanation

Confidentiality is strong but not absolute, and recognised exceptions permit disclosure where necessary to prevent serious, imminent harm. The lawyer's role is to consider a measured response, not to take physical action or broadcast the information publicly.

Question 19Professional Responsibility

What is the principal ethical concern when a lawyer's fee arrangement gives the lawyer a share of the client's recovery?

  1. Ensuring the client is unaware of the percentage until the end
  2. Ensuring the arrangement is kept confidential from the court
  3. Ensuring the arrangement is fair, disclosed, and does not impair the lawyer's independent judgment Correct answer.
  4. Ensuring the lawyer receives the largest possible share of the recovery

Explanation

Contingency arrangements are permissible in many contexts but must be fair, transparent, and structured so that the lawyer's own interest in the recovery does not distort professional judgment. Maximising the lawyer's share or hiding terms undermines the client's informed choice.

Question 20Professional Responsibility

Which behaviour best demonstrates the professional value of courtesy in dealings with opposing counsel?

  1. Refusing extensions even where no prejudice would result
  2. Responding to reasonable requests promptly and refraining from personal attacks Correct answer.
  3. Ignoring correspondence to gain a tactical advantage
  4. Making disparaging remarks about opposing counsel in open court

Explanation

Courtesy requires civility and reasonable cooperation with opposing counsel, including prompt responses and restraint from personal attacks. Tactical silence, insults, and reflexive refusals are inconsistent with the professional expectation of civility.

Question 21Professional Responsibility

A lawyer suspects that a client is using the lawyer's services to further a fraud. What is the appropriate response?

  1. Decline to assist further and consider whether withdrawal or disclosure obligations are triggered Correct answer.
  2. Continue acting and share the suspicion only with the client's business partners
  3. Continue acting and rely on the client's assurances without further inquiry
  4. Continue acting but avoid putting anything in writing

Explanation

A lawyer must not knowingly assist in a fraud and should make reasonable inquiries where suspicion arises. If the concern is substantiated, the lawyer should decline to assist further and consider withdrawal and any disclosure obligations.

Question 22Professional Responsibility

What does the duty to communicate with a client generally require?

  1. Delegating all client communication to the opposing party
  2. Withholding adverse developments to avoid worrying the client
  3. Communicating only when a bill is issued
  4. Keeping the client reasonably informed about significant developments and responding to inquiries Correct answer.

Explanation

Lawyers must keep clients reasonably informed about the matter and respond to reasonable requests for information. Limiting contact to billing or concealing adverse developments deprives the client of the ability to make informed decisions.

Question 23Professional Responsibility

A lawyer moves to a new firm and has confidential information about a former client whose interests are adverse to a client of the new firm. What is the appropriate approach?

  1. Proceed and rely on the lawyer's personal assurance of impartiality
  2. Proceed without screening because the lawyer's knowledge is merely background
  3. Disclose the former client's confidences to the new firm to assess the conflict
  4. Screen the lawyer from the matter and assess whether the former client's confidences are protected Correct answer.

Explanation

When a lawyer changes firms, the new firm must assess whether the former client's confidential information can be protected, often through screening and restrictions. Relying on personal assurances or sharing the confidences with the new firm does not adequately protect the former client.

Question 24Professional Responsibility

Which of the following best describes the professional obligation of a lawyer who is asked to act on a matter clearly outside their competence and with no time to become competent?

  1. Decline the retainer or refer the matter to a lawyer with the required competence Correct answer.
  2. Accept the retainer because clients bear the risk of choosing counsel
  3. Accept the retainer and disclose the lack of competence only if something goes wrong
  4. Accept the retainer and improvise as the matter proceeds

Explanation

Competence is a threshold requirement, and where a lawyer cannot become competent in the time available, the matter should be declined or referred. Improvising or disclosing the gap only after a problem arises exposes the client to avoidable harm.

Question 25Professional Responsibility

What is the significance of a lawyer's undertaking given to another party in a transaction?

  1. It is merely a courtesy and can be withdrawn at will
  2. It binds only the client and not the lawyer
  3. It is a personal professional commitment that must be honoured strictly Correct answer.
  4. It is enforceable only if the court approves it in advance

Explanation

An undertaking is a personal commitment by the lawyer that must be honoured strictly and without delay, and failure to do so is a serious professional matter. It is not a mere courtesy and does not depend on prior court approval.

Question 26Professional Responsibility

A lawyer is retained by a new client in a matter unrelated to any prior representation. Which duty requires the lawyer to keep the new client's information secret from third parties?

  1. The duty to account for trust funds
  2. The duty of candour to the court
  3. The duty to promote access to justice
  4. The duty of confidentiality Correct answer.

Explanation

Confidentiality obliges a lawyer to keep information learned in the professional relationship secret, and it survives the end of the retainer. It is broader than the evidentiary privilege that protects certain communications from disclosure in legal proceedings.

Question 27Professional Responsibility

A lawyer is appointed to act for a client whose case falls within an area of law the lawyer has never handled. Which step best satisfies the duty of competence?

  1. Rely on the client to supply the relevant legal authorities
  2. Take the matter only after acquiring the necessary knowledge or associating with a competent lawyer Correct answer.
  3. Decline the appointment without further inquiry
  4. Accept the brief and learn the law as the case proceeds

Explanation

Competence requires the lawyer to possess, or to acquire before acting, the legal knowledge and skill reasonably necessary for the matter. A lawyer may take on unfamiliar work if adequate preparation, study, or association with a competent colleague occurs.

Question 28Professional Responsibility

Which statement best describes a lawyer's duty when holding client money in a trust account?

  1. Client funds may be used temporarily to cover the firm's operating shortfall
  2. Client funds may be released to the lawyer as soon as a fee note is drafted
  3. Client funds may be pooled with the lawyer's funds if the firm keeps a single ledger
  4. Client funds must be kept separate from the lawyer's own money and disbursed only as authorised Correct answer.

Explanation

Trust money must be held separately from the lawyer's own funds and applied only for the purpose for which it was entrusted. Meticulous records and prompt accounting to the client are integral to this duty.

Question 29Professional Responsibility

A lawyer discovers that a former client's confidential information is relevant to a new matter for a different client whose interests are adverse. What is the safest professional course?

  1. Disclose the former client's information to the new client with a warning
  2. Proceed because the former retainer has ended
  3. Decline or withdraw from the new matter unless the former client gives informed consent Correct answer.
  4. Proceed but avoid mentioning the former client's name in documents

Explanation

The duty of confidentiality continues after the retainer ends, so a lawyer generally cannot act against a former client where confidential information could be used against them. Acting is permissible only where there is no risk of misuse or where the former client gives informed consent.

Question 30Professional Responsibility

What is the principal purpose of a lawyer's duty of candour toward the court?

  1. To guarantee that the lawyer's client wins the case
  2. To prevent the lawyer from ever making an adverse concession
  3. To require the lawyer to disclose every document the client possesses
  4. To ensure the court is not misled by the lawyer's submissions or evidence Correct answer.

Explanation

Candour requires the lawyer not to mislead the tribunal and to correct any misleading statement promptly. The duty is owed to the court and sits alongside, not above, the lawyer's obligations to the client.

Question 31Professional Responsibility

A lawyer is asked by a client to prepare a document that the lawyer knows will be used to mislead a third party. What should the lawyer do?

  1. Refuse to prepare the document and advise the client against the course Correct answer.
  2. Prepare it and rely on the client's assurances
  3. Prepare it if the wording is technically accurate
  4. Prepare it but keep no record of the instructions

Explanation

A lawyer must not assist in conduct the lawyer knows is dishonest or fraudulent, even where the wording could be defended as literally true. The lawyer should decline and advise the client of the lawful alternatives.

Question 32Professional Responsibility

A lawyer is instructed to act for a client in a matter in which the lawyer's spouse has a direct financial interest adverse to the client. What is the appropriate professional response?

  1. Act, because a personal interest is not a conflict of interest
  2. Act, provided the lawyer does not discuss the matter at home
  3. Act, because the spouse's interest is legally separate from the lawyer's
  4. Disclose the interest and decline unless the client gives informed consent and the conflict can be managed Correct answer.

Explanation

A personal or financial interest of the lawyer or a close family member that conflicts with the client's interest must be disclosed, and the lawyer should decline unless informed consent is obtained and the risk is manageable.

Question 33Professional Responsibility

Which of the following best describes the professional obligation of a lawyer regarding continuing legal education?

  1. It is a personal choice with no professional dimension
  2. It is an ongoing professional responsibility to maintain and update competence Correct answer.
  3. It is required only in the first year after admission
  4. It is satisfied by reading newspapers occasionally

Explanation

Competence is a continuing duty, so lawyers are expected to keep their knowledge and skills current throughout practice. Many regulators give this duty concrete form through mandatory continuing education requirements.

Question 34Professional Responsibility

A lawyer acting for a client in a negotiation receives a settlement offer that expires in 24 hours. The client cannot be reached. What should the lawyer do?

  1. Accept the offer because it appears favourable
  2. Reject the offer to preserve the client's options
  3. Accept the offer subject to the client's later approval
  4. Seek an extension of time and continue trying to obtain the client's instructions Correct answer.

Explanation

Settling a matter is a decision for the client, so the lawyer must obtain instructions before accepting. Where a deadline threatens the client's position, the lawyer should seek more time and keep trying to communicate.

Question 35Professional Responsibility

A lawyer proposes a fee arrangement in which the lawyer is paid a percentage of whatever damages the client recovers. Which concern is most directly engaged?

  1. The lawyer's personal interest may colour advice about whether to settle Correct answer.
  2. The client will necessarily receive less than under an hourly fee
  3. The court must approve every such arrangement in advance
  4. The lawyer becomes a party to the litigation

Explanation

A contingency fee aligns the lawyer's reward with the size of the recovery, which can create pressure to favour a larger award over the client's broader interests, such as speed or certainty. Regulators typically require such arrangements to be fair, disclosed, and permitted by law.

Question 36Professional Responsibility

A lawyer learns during a retainer that the client has given false evidence in an affidavit already filed. What is the appropriate professional response?

  1. Report the client to the police immediately in every case
  2. Say nothing because the affidavit has already been filed
  3. Advise the client to correct the evidence and, if the client refuses, take steps to withdraw or disclose as the rules require Correct answer.
  4. Quietly amend the affidavit without telling the court

Explanation

A lawyer must not continue to rely on evidence the lawyer knows to be false, and should first encourage the client to correct it. If the client refuses, the lawyer may need to withdraw or make disclosure to the court in accordance with the applicable rules.

Question 37Professional Responsibility

A lawyer is offered a brief by a client whose instructions would require the lawyer to act in a way that offends the lawyer's deeply held moral beliefs. What is the appropriate approach?

  1. Accept the brief and lecture the client about the lawyer's values
  2. Decline the brief promptly so the client can instruct another lawyer Correct answer.
  3. Accept the brief and later seek to withdraw once the issue arises
  4. Accept the brief but perform the work poorly to discourage the client

Explanation

A lawyer may decline a matter that conflicts with personal convictions, provided the refusal is communicated promptly so the client is not prejudiced. Once retained, a lawyer cannot simply perform inadequately because of disagreement with the client.

Question 38Professional Responsibility

A client asks a lawyer to hold back a document that the client is legally obliged to produce under a court order. What should the lawyer do?

  1. Resign from the matter without explanation
  2. Comply, because the document belongs to the client
  3. Comply, because the lawyer must follow all client instructions
  4. Refuse to conceal the document and advise the client of the obligation to produce it Correct answer.

Explanation

A lawyer must not assist a client to breach a court order or conceal material that must be produced. The lawyer should explain the legal obligation and, if the client persists, consider whether withdrawal is required.

Question 39Professional Responsibility

What is the principal ethical concern raised by a lawyer advertising services with a claim that the lawyer is the best in the field?

  1. It is prohibited because all advertising is banned
  2. It is acceptable because advertising is unregulated
  3. It is acceptable only if the client consents
  4. It may be misleading if it cannot be substantiated Correct answer.

Explanation

Advertising must be accurate and not create unjustified expectations, so unverifiable superlatives risk misleading the public. Regulators generally permit advertising but impose truthfulness and dignity requirements.

Question 40Professional Responsibility

A lawyer is asked to act for a client against a company in which the lawyer owns a significant shareholding. What should the lawyer do first?

  1. Sell the shares after the matter concludes
  2. Act, because the company is a separate legal person
  3. Act, because shareholdings are private financial matters
  4. Disclose the shareholding and assess whether the conflict can be managed or must lead to refusal Correct answer.

Explanation

A direct financial interest adverse to the client creates a conflict that must be identified and addressed openly. Depending on the size and nature of the interest, the lawyer may need to decline or obtain informed consent where permitted.

Question 41Professional Responsibility

A lawyer receives a court document that appears to have been sent to the lawyer in error and contains the opposing party's privileged advice. What is the appropriate response?

  1. Notify the sender promptly and follow the applicable rules on inadvertent disclosure Correct answer.
  2. Read it carefully and use anything helpful at trial
  3. Destroy it without telling anyone
  4. Read it and use it only if the opponent does not object

Explanation

A lawyer who receives material that appears privileged and was likely sent in error should notify the sender and avoid using it pending resolution. The precise procedure is set by the applicable rules of professional conduct and procedure.

Question 42Professional Responsibility

A lawyer is asked to sign a certificate confirming that a client has complied with certain requirements, but the lawyer has not verified compliance. What should the lawyer do?

  1. Sign with a note that the certificate is unverified
  2. Sign, because certificates are a formality
  3. Sign, because the client has assured the lawyer of compliance
  4. Refuse to sign until the lawyer has taken reasonable steps to verify compliance Correct answer.

Explanation

A lawyer who signs a certificate or gives an undertaking takes professional responsibility for its accuracy. Signing without reasonable verification risks misleading the recipient and exposing the lawyer to disciplinary consequences.

Question 43Professional Responsibility

Which statement best explains why a lawyer must avoid a relationship with a client that goes beyond the professional one?

  1. It increases the lawyer's insurance premiums
  2. Clients are not permitted to socialise with lawyers
  3. Personal involvement may impair the lawyer's independent judgment and objectivity Correct answer.
  4. Such relationships are automatically void in law

Explanation

The professional relationship depends on detachment and loyalty, and a close personal or financial entanglement can cloud the lawyer's judgment. Rules commonly restrict personal relationships with clients or require heightened safeguards.

Question 44Professional Responsibility

A lawyer is asked to represent a client in a matter that the lawyer believes is legally weak but not frivolous. What is the appropriate professional approach?

  1. Present only the strongest points and conceal the weaknesses
  2. Advise the client candidly on the merits and, if instructed, present the case competently Correct answer.
  3. Promise the client a favourable outcome to build confidence
  4. Refuse, because weak cases waste the court's time

Explanation

Clients are entitled to have arguable cases presented, and a lawyer's view of the merits does not justify abandoning the client. The lawyer must give honest advice about prospects while advocating the case properly and without misleading the court.

Question 45Professional Responsibility

A lawyer acting for a client in litigation is asked by the client to communicate directly with the opposing party, who is represented by counsel. What should the lawyer do?

  1. Refuse to communicate directly and deal with opposing counsel instead Correct answer.
  2. Communicate directly if the opposing party agrees
  3. Communicate directly but keep the conversation informal
  4. Communicate directly because the client has authorised it

Explanation

A lawyer generally must not communicate about the matter with a party the lawyer knows to be represented by counsel, unless counsel consents. The rule protects the opposing party and preserves the integrity of the adversarial process.

Question 46Professional Responsibility

A lawyer is asked to act in a matter where the lawyer's former client is now the opposing party in a substantially related transaction. What is the governing principle?

  1. The lawyer may act because the former client is no longer a client
  2. The lawyer may act if the former client has moved to another city
  3. The lawyer must not act where confidential information from the former retainer could be used against the former client Correct answer.
  4. The lawyer may act if the new client pays a higher fee

Explanation

A lawyer is generally barred from acting against a former client in a substantially related matter where confidential information could be used to the former client's disadvantage. The test focuses on the relationship between the two matters and the risk of misuse of information.

Question 47Professional Responsibility

A lawyer discovers that a colleague in the same firm has been misappropriating client trust funds. What is the appropriate professional response?

  1. Report the matter to the relevant authority and take steps to protect affected clients Correct answer.
  2. Say nothing to protect the firm's reputation
  3. Wait to see whether the colleague repays the money
  4. Repay the funds quietly and take no further action

Explanation

Misappropriation of trust funds is a serious breach that must be reported to the regulator, and affected clients must be protected. Concealing the conduct exposes clients to further loss and makes the lawyer complicit.

Question 48Professional Responsibility

A lawyer is instructed by a corporate client through its chief executive, but the board later indicates that the chief executive's instructions conflict with the company's interests. What should the lawyer do?

  1. Ask the chief executive to resign before continuing
  2. Follow the chief executive's instructions because that is the established channel
  3. Withdraw immediately without explanation
  4. Treat the board as the client and seek clarification of the company's instructions Correct answer.

Explanation

Where the client is a corporation, the lawyer's duty runs to the entity, and authority to instruct normally rests with its proper governing organs. When instructions conflict, the lawyer should seek clarification from the board rather than simply following one officer.

Question 49Professional Responsibility

A lawyer is asked to act for two clients in the same transaction where one client's interests are aligned at the outset but may diverge later. What is the appropriate professional approach?

  1. Act for both and keep each client's instructions secret from the other
  2. Act for both and disclose the risk of future divergence, obtaining informed consent where permitted Correct answer.
  3. Act for one client only and inform the other client after completion
  4. Act for both without discussion because the interests currently align

Explanation

A joint retainer requires the lawyer to explain the risk that interests may later conflict and to obtain informed consent where the rules permit joint representation. If a material conflict later arises, the lawyer may have to withdraw from acting for one or both clients.

Question 50Professional Responsibility

A lawyer is offered a position on the board of a company that is a current client. Which concern is most significant from a professional responsibility perspective?

  1. The lawyer's dual role may impair independent judgment and create conflicts of duty and interest Correct answer.
  2. The lawyer will be unable to bill the client for board time
  3. The lawyer may learn information that is useful to other clients
  4. The lawyer's firm may need to change its name

Explanation

Serving as a director of a client can compromise the lawyer's independence because the fiduciary duties of a director may conflict with the duties of a legal adviser. Regulators typically require careful assessment, disclosure, and sometimes avoidance of the dual role.