Conflicting Flange Adapter Dimensions and Bolt-Hole Layout
A fabricator is building a bolted flange adapter. The assembly drawing gives a face-to-face dimension of 2450 mm ±3 mm. The detail drawing shows a 1620 mm nozzle and an 830 mm shell; a general note says 'allow 6 mm for gasket and joint take-up.' The flange has 16 equally spaced holes on a 1050 mm bolt circle, with the first hole on the vertical centerline. The shop's layout table is available, but the only tape is a 5 m Class II; dividers and a CNC plasma table are also available. A fitter has already marked the first hole and is about to step off 16 chords of 205 mm using the tape, because 205 mm is the dimension shown in a shop sketch. The client wants the adapter delivered in three days. The inspector is off site until tomorrow.
1. Identify the dimensional conflict and state how it should be resolved before any cutting or drilling.
Read the worked answer
The detail dimensions sum to 1620 + 830 = 2450 mm, which matches the assembly face-to-face dimension. The general note then adds 6 mm for gasket and joint take-up, giving 2456 mm. The drawing therefore does not tell the shop whether 2450 mm is the finished installed face-to-face dimension including the gasket or the metal-to-metal fabrication length before the gasket allowance. That is a conflict that must be resolved by a documented request for information, not by guessing. Fabrication should be held on the affected parts until the designer confirms the controlling dimension. The shop should record the RFI, the drawing revision, and the answer. The assembly dimension and the general note cannot both be applied blindly.
2. Calculate the exact chord between adjacent holes and the closure error if the fitter uses 205 mm per space. Is the shop sketch acceptable for layout?
Read the worked answer
Bolt-circle radius = 1050 / 2 = 525 mm. Central angle between holes = 360° / 16 = 22.5°. Exact chord = 2 × 525 × sin(22.5° / 2) = 1050 × sin(11.25°) = 1050 × 0.19509 = 204.84 mm. If the fitter steps 205 mm for 16 spaces, the total stepped distance is 16 × 205 = 3280 mm, while 16 exact chords total 16 × 204.84 = 3277.4 mm. The closure error is 3280 - 3277.4 = 2.6 mm. That error is in addition to tape reading and marking error, and it accumulates around the flange. The 205 mm sketch value is therefore not acceptable as a layout dimension for a 16-hole bolt circle; the exact chord or coordinate layout should be used.
3. Describe the layout and verification sequence you would use for the 16-hole flange.
Read the worked answer
I would prefer CNC plasma marking or a coordinate layout from the bolt-circle center, because cumulative manual error is avoided. For manual layout, mark the center, scribe the 1050 mm bolt circle, and establish vertical and horizontal centerlines. Set dividers to 204.84 mm, step around the circle, and check closure back to the first hole. Then check opposite holes for 180° spacing, check the bolt-circle diameter, and confirm the first hole is on the vertical centerline. Center-punch and drill pilot holes only after the layout is checked. A template or a rotary table is better than stepping with a tape. The final check should include hole-to-hole chord, bolt-circle diameter, and flange orientation relative to the mating part.