Café at a Loss: Close, Reprice, or Reshape?
You manage the retail cafe in a 250-bed hospital. The cafe serves an average of 380 transactions per operating day across 22 days per month. The average check is $6.75; food and paper cost runs 36% of sales; fixed monthly costs (labor, utilities, equipment, allocated space) are $38,000. The cafe also provides 40 free meals per day to on-call physicians and volunteers, each costing $5.00 in variable cost. A fast-food chain is opening half a mile away, and finance projects cafe volume will fall 20% within 60 days. Administration wants a recommendation: close the cafe, raise prices, or change the operation. The strategic plan emphasizes employee and physician satisfaction, and the cafe is the only food outlet within walking distance for the night shift.
1. Calculate current monthly profit or loss and the break-even transactions per day, including the free-meal cost.
Read the worked answer
Current economics (per month, 22 operating days)
- Transactions: 380 x 22 = 8,360
- Sales: 8,360 x $6.75 = $56,430
- Food and paper: 36% x $56,430 = $20,314.80
- Free meals: 40 x $5.00 x 22 = $4,400 in variable cost with no revenue
- Total variable: $24,714.80
- Contribution: $56,430 - $24,714.80 = $31,715.20
- Fixed: $38,000
- Net: $31,715.20 - $38,000 = -$6,284.80 per month
The cafe is already losing money before the competitor opens.
Break-even
- Contribution per paid transaction: $6.75 x 0.64 = $4.32
- Required contribution: $38,000 fixed + $4,400 free meals = $42,400
- Break-even transactions per month: $42,400 / $4.32 = 9,814.8, round to 9,815
- Per operating day: 9,815 / 22 = 446.1, so about 447 transactions per day
Current volume of 380 is roughly 67 transactions per day short of break-even. The free-meal program alone accounts for about 46 transactions per day of the gap - it is not a rounding error.
2. Finance projects a 20% volume drop. Quantify the resulting loss and evaluate three options.
Read the worked answer
After the 20% drop
- Transactions: 380 x 0.80 = 304 per day; 304 x 22 = 6,688 per month
- Sales: 6,688 x $6.75 = $45,144
- Food and paper: 36% x $45,144 = $16,251.84
- Free meals: $4,400
- Contribution: $45,144 - $20,651.84 = $24,492.16
- Net: $24,492.16 - $38,000 = -$13,507.84 per month (about -$162,000 annualized)
Option A: close. The $38,000 is not all avoidable. Assume 60% is avoidable (hourly labor, utilities, supplies, some maintenance) = $22,800, and 40% is committed or allocated (space, depreciation, salaried management) = $15,200. Closing therefore leaves a -$15,200 monthly charge, which is worse than the -$13,508 of staying open. The decision turns entirely on the avoidable-cost split: if 70% is avoidable, the committed cost falls to $11,400 and closing becomes the cheaper choice by about $2,100 per month. Run this analysis with finance before recommending anything.
Option B: raise price to $7.25 (+7.4%). Contribution per transaction becomes $7.25 x 0.64 = $4.64. At unchanged volume: 6,688 x $4.64 = $31,032, net -$11,368. That improves the loss by about $2,140 but does not close it, and it assumes no volume loss - unrealistic when a cheaper competitor just opened. A 5% volume loss (289/day) gives 6,358 x $4.64 = $29,501, net -$12,899. Pricing alone cannot fix a volume problem this size.
Option C: reduce the cost structure and the free-meal obligation. Cutting the 40 free meals to 25 saves 15 x $5.00 x 22 = $1,650 per month. Closing after the 2:00 p.m. lull, or converting the evening to grab-and-go, could remove $8,000-$10,000 in fixed labor while sacrificing some volume. Combined with a modest price increase to $7.10 (contribution $4.544), break-even becomes ($38,000 + $2,750) / $4.544 = 8,965 per month, or 408 per day.
3. Make a recommendation and identify the non-financial factors and the trigger for revisiting it.
Read the worked answer
Recommendation: do not close now. Reshape and set a decision trigger.
The financial case for closing is weaker than the headline loss suggests, because most of the fixed cost does not disappear when the doors shut. A $13,500 monthly loss against $15,200 in unavoidable cost is a thin margin - but it still favors operating, and the non-financial case is stronger than that.
Actions, in order
- Verify the avoidable-fixed-cost split with finance. This single number decides the question. Everything else is secondary.
- Right-size the free-meal program. Move from 40 open meals to a voucher or badge system for on-call physicians and volunteers, capped at 25 per day. Saves roughly $1,650 per month and makes the subsidy visible and budgeted rather than buried in the cafe's P&L.
- Re-price selectively, not across the board: raise the highest-margin, least price-sensitive items (coffee, bottled drinks, packaged snacks) and hold or bundle the value items so the price-sensitive night shift is not driven away.
- Attack volume. Pre-order and app-based pickup for the night shift, meal deals, a physician rounding cart, and marketing to the adjacent buildings. The competitor took the walk-in customer; capture the customer who cannot leave the building.
- Match capacity to demand. Reduce evening hours or convert to self-service grab-and-go, and redeploy labor rather than cutting positions.
Non-financial factors
- Night-shift access to food affects retention and safety; the cafe is the only option within walking distance.
- Physician and visitor satisfaction scores, and the hospital's strategic plan, both count the cafe as an asset.
- Closing damages the employer brand in a tight labor market and is difficult to reverse.
Decision trigger
- If monthly loss exceeds the confirmed unavoidable fixed cost (about $15,200) for three consecutive months, close or renegotiate the space.
- If volume stabilizes above 410 transactions per day after the changes, the operation is viable and should be retained.
- If volume falls below 280 per day, begin space repurposing planning immediately regardless of the cost split.
- Review at 90 days with actual transaction data, not the projection.