A liability allegation and a policy response
A fictional business receives a third-party claim alleging damage caused during its work. It notifies an insurer and sends the available contract and incident records. The policy covers a defined risk during a stated period and contains conditions and exclusions that have not yet been fully examined. The claimant says the existence of an insurance policy proves liability and guarantees payment of the entire claimed amount. A staff member makes the opposite assumption that an insurer request for more information proves there is no liability at all. Students must separate the alleged legal wrong, the proof and amount of loss, and the insurer actual contractual response. The exercise does not supply a complete policy or establish that any particular exclusion applies.
1. Which issues are separate?
Read the worked answer
The insured legal liability, the recoverable loss and the insurer contractual cover each require their own analysis. Neither policy existence nor an information request establishes all three.
2. What should be examined next?
Read the worked answer
Identify the cause of action and evidence, then review the actual insured risk, period, conditions and relevant exclusions. Communicate the unresolved matters without guaranteeing a payment or denial.