CHEST study materials
CHEST study resources

Thirty-Six Hours on the Medical Unit

CHEST · Put your knowledge to work in context.

All case studies

Thirty-Six Hours on the Medical Unit

Over 36 hours, six patients and three staff on your 32-bed unit develop vomiting and watery diarrhea. The unit has one shared shower room, four vital-signs machines, and two wheelchairs. Symptomatic patients are not yet cohorted and share a bathroom with asymptomatic patients. Tonight's EVS staffing is you, one other technician, and an agency technician on her first shift at this facility who has not been oriented to the outbreak protocol. Alcohol-based hand rub is mounted at every doorway. The disinfectant in use is a quaternary ammonium product labeled for a 60-second contact time. A family member asks you why the room "smells like it wasn't cleaned," and a nurse asks you to "just do the discharge rooms first - the restrooms can wait."

1. What is wrong with the current product and hand-hygiene approach, and what do you change?

Read the worked answer

Product. Norovirus is a non-enveloped virus; quaternary ammonium at a 60-second contact time is not a reliable choice. Switch to an EPA-registered product with a norovirus claim (List G) used at its full label contact time, or a chlorine solution in the 1,000–5,000 ppm range with roughly a 5-minute wet contact time, per facility policy and surface compatibility. Shortening contact time under outbreak pressure defeats the purpose.

Hand hygiene. Alcohol-based rub is relatively ineffective against norovirus. Soap and water is preferred for staff and visitors during an outbreak, especially after contact with the patient or the environment and before eating. Ensure soap and paper towels are stocked at every sink - including the shared bathroom and the shower room - and that dispensers are not empty at 02:00.

Also check: whether cleaning cloths and mop heads are changed between outbreak rooms (they must be), whether the shower room is being cleaned between patients, and whether any soft surfaces or equipment in the affected rooms can be swapped for cleanable alternatives.

The persistent error in outbreaks is doing the normal routine harder. The routine itself has to change.

2. With three staff, sequence the shift. Which areas come first, and what happens to shared equipment?

Read the worked answer

Rank by how many people a surface can reach. A shared bathroom, the shower room, and shared equipment can transmit to dozens of patients; a discharge room reaches one new occupant. That ordering drives the night:

  1. Shared bathrooms and the shower room - cleaned and disinfected on a defined frequency, and after use by any symptomatic patient, with the appropriate product and full contact time.
  2. High-touch surfaces in symptomatic patients' rooms - bed rails, call buttons, overbed tables, door handles, light switches.
  3. Shared equipment - vital-signs machines, wheelchairs, blood pressure cuffs, commodes - dedicated to symptomatic patients where possible and disinfected between every patient when not.
  4. Terminal cleans of outbreak rooms and discharges - necessary for admissions, but they do not outrank a contaminated shared bathroom unless a bed is clinically critical, in which case say so and get the decision made explicitly.

Cohorting. Raise it with the charge nurse and infection prevention: symptomatic patients in one area with a dedicated bathroom, and staff assigned consistently to well or ill patients where staffing allows. EVS can flag it but does not decide it - escalate rather than improvise.

Communicate the plan out loud at the start of the shift so the nurse knows when the bathrooms will be done, not just that they will be done eventually.

3. How do you direct the agency technician, and how do you answer the nurse who wants restrooms postponed?

Read the worked answer

The agency tech. First shift, no outbreak orientation - she cannot be sent into an outbreak room with a general orientation and a bucket. Options in order: pair her with you or the other technician for the shift, assign her only non-outbreak areas until she has been briefed, or brief her properly for ten minutes before she touches anything. The briefing covers: the product, the dilution or readiness, the full contact time, which rooms are affected, what PPE, cloth and mop changes, hand hygiene with soap and water, and whom to ask when unsure. Notify your supervisor that an agency worker arrived without outbreak orientation - that is a system gap, not her fault, and it will recur tomorrow night if nobody records it.

The nurse. 'Restrooms can't wait all shift - they're the highest-spread surfaces we have. Here's the order: shared bathroom and shower room first, then the outbreak rooms, then discharges. I can have the first discharge room done by 22:15.' Give a time rather than a yes or no. If she still wants discharges first, ask her to take it to the charge nurse or house supervisor so the trade-off is visible and owned above your level.

The family member gets a straight answer, not defensiveness: what you are cleaning, that you are using a product that works against the outbreak organism, and when you will be back in the room.