Woodworking Losses: Business or Hobby Under §183?
Eduardo earns $78,000 as a high school teacher. Since 2021 he has run a custom woodworking activity from his garage, spending about 20 hours per week on evenings and weekends. He has a separate bank account, business cards, a website, and sells at craft fairs. He bought a $22,000 CNC router in 2021 and has deducted depreciation, materials, insurance, and advertising. Gross receipts were $3,000 in 2021, $6,000 in 2022, $9,000 in 2023, and $12,000 in 2024; expenses have exceeded receipts every year by at least $8,000. He has no written business plan, no formal marketing budget, and says he enjoys the work and hopes to make money after he retires. He has never had a profitable year. On audit, the IRS proposes to disallow the Schedule C losses and treat the activity as a hobby. Eduardo asks whether the losses can be defended and what the consequences are.
1. Apply the §183 profit-motive factors to Eduardo's facts. Is the activity a business or a hobby? Address the 3-of-5-year presumption.
Read the worked answer
Section 183 disallows losses from an activity not engaged in for profit. The nine factors include: manner of conducting the activity, expertise, time and effort, expectation of appreciation, success in similar activities, history of income and losses, amount of occasional profits, financial status, and personal pleasure. No one factor controls. Eduardo has some business indicia: separate bank account, cards, website, regular sales, and substantial time. Against him: four consecutive loss years, no written plan, no formal marketing budget, substantial outside income, personal enjoyment, and no evidence he studied business management. His hope of profit after retirement is subjective.
The §183(d) presumption requires net income in 3 of 5 consecutive years (2 of 7 for horse activities). He has none, so no presumption applies and he bears the burden. On these facts, a hobby reclassification is likely.
2. If the IRS prevails, what happens to the income, expenses, depreciation, and self-employment tax?
Read the worked answer
If the IRS prevails, the activity is not a trade or business. Gross receipts are still included in income, typically as other income on Schedule 1. Deductions are limited by §183(b): first, deductions allowable regardless of profit motive, such as state and local taxes or mortgage interest, if applicable; second, other hobby expenses only up to gross income. However, for 2018–2025, §67(g) suspends miscellaneous itemized deductions, so the second category is effectively unavailable to an individual. Depreciation on the CNC router is a §183(b)(2) deduction and is disallowed. The income is not subject to self-employment tax because it is not a trade or business. The previously claimed Schedule C losses are disallowed, and the IRS may impose a 20% accuracy-related penalty under §6662 if the underpayment is due to negligence or substantial understatement; interest also runs.
3. What steps could Eduardo take to improve his position, and what election might help?
Read the worked answer
To improve his position, Eduardo should run the activity in a businesslike manner: adopt a written business plan with profit projections, set prices using cost data, track hours and expenses separately, maintain a dedicated business account, advertise, and consult a business advisor. He should document any effort to improve profitability and avoid treating the activity primarily as recreation. He could elect under §183(e) to postpone the profit-motive determination until after the fifth taxable year, but that election must be timely and does not cure past years. Reaching three profitable years within a five-year period would create the §183(d) presumption prospectively, but it cannot be manufactured retroactively.