The Evacuation Tone and the Division Chief
At 19:20, you are the acting company officer of Truck 9 at a two-story brick two-flat. Engine 33 reports a rear bedroom fire on the second floor knocked down. Your four firefighters are on the second floor opening the ceiling. The safety officer, a battalion chief, sounds the evacuation tone and radios, 'All companies evacuate; we have a partial roof collapse over the rear.' At the same moment, your division chief, standing 15 feet away, says, 'Hold your people. The fire's out and we need that ceiling opened for overhaul.' The evacuation tone continues. Through a window you can see the rear roof sagging near the chimney, and you hear something shift. Your crew is looking at you for direction.
1. What do you do immediately, and why?
Read the worked answer
I would order my crew out immediately. I would use both the radio and direct voice: 'Truck 9 to command, Truck 9 is evacuating.' On the floor, I would tell the four firefighters to leave the ceiling, use the stairs if they are clear, and go to the exterior meeting point. No tools, no finishing the opening.
At the exterior, I would account for all four by name and report a PAR to the accountability officer or IC.
Why: the evacuation tone is a fireground emergency signal, and the safety officer has ordered all companies out. The roof is visibly sagging and something has shifted; those are signs of impending structural failure, not a routine overhaul condition. Firefighter life safety outranks completing the ceiling opening. A partial roof collapse can extend quickly, and the seconds spent debating are seconds the crew cannot use to get out. The division chief may not have seen the sag from his position, but that does not change what I can see.
2. How do you handle the division chief's order - during the evacuation and afterward?
Read the worked answer
During the evacuation: I would be brief and respectful but act. Something like: 'Chief, safety officer sounded evacuation and the rear roof is sagging. I'm pulling my crew now; I'll report to you at the front.' I would not stand there and argue, and I would not pretend to comply while leaving my crew inside. The tone is already sounding, and my crew needs a clear signal from me.
Afterward: I would report to the division chief and the safety officer together, describe what I observed from the window, and ask for a structural assessment before anyone re-enters. If the division chief continued to insist on re-entry before an assessment, I would escalate to the incident commander and the safety officer, because the evacuation order is still in effect and I am not authorized to cancel it.
Reasoning: this is a conflict between a direct order and a safety order. The safe course is to evacuate first and resolve the conflict outside the hazard zone. I would document the sequence afterward: the evacuation tone, the safety officer's message, my evacuation order, the PAR, and the division chief's instruction.
3. One firefighter is not at the PAR. What do you do now?
Read the worked answer
I would treat it as an immediate emergency. First, notify the incident commander and accountability officer by radio: give the firefighter's name, last known location on the second floor, and air status. I would request that the rapid intervention team be activated and that the evacuation be maintained.
I would not send individual members back inside to search on their own. A search for a missing firefighter is a coordinated operation with a charged line, full PPE, and a team, usually the RIC. If the firefighter is unaccounted for and possibly trapped, a mayday should be transmitted clearly and the IC should control the rescue.
At the same time, I would keep the rest of my crew together at the exterior and recheck the names; sometimes a member has exited to a different side of the building or is with another company. I would report any correction immediately. The priority is a clear, accurate report to command, not a solo search.