Five Beers for a Four-Course Gastropub Dinner
A gastropub asks you to pair five beers with a four-course menu for a 60-guest dinner. Menu: raw oysters with mignonette; gochujang-glazed fried chicken; braised lamb shoulder with mint gremolata; dark chocolate tart with raspberry coulis. Beers: Berliner weisse 3.2% ABV, pH 3.2; saison 6.8% ABV, 30 IBU, dry; West Coast IPA 7.2% ABV, 70 IBU; doppelbock 7.5% ABV, 25 IBU, malty; imperial stout 10% ABV, 60 IBU, sweet. Guests include a pescatarian, a guest who dislikes bitter, and a guest who wants one beer for the whole meal. The kitchen can adjust one dish's seasoning but not its core protein. The event is in three weeks, and the beers are already contracted. You must give the service team a one-page pairing sheet with pour sizes and backup options.
1. Assign one beer per course and justify each pairing using intensity, carbonation, acid, bitterness, and sweetness.
Read the worked answer
Course pairings:
- Oysters + Berliner weisse – acid and carbonation cut salinity and richness; low alcohol keeps the palate fresh. Saison is the backup if a guest dislikes sour.
- Gochujang fried chicken + West Coast IPA – bitterness and carbonation cut fat; hop fruit and bitterness can meet the sweet-spicy glaze. For a bitter-averse guest, use saison.
- Lamb shoulder + doppelbock – malt sweetness and Maillard notes bridge browned meat; carbonation scrubs fat; 25 IBU will not fight the mint gremolata.
- Chocolate tart + imperial stout – roast, bitter, and sweet match the chocolate; raspberry acid cuts richness. Berliner weisse is a contrast option but may be too thin.
Pour sizes should be smaller for the 10% stout and 7.2% IPA, and full pours for the 3.2% Berliner. Keep water on the table; high-ABV beers and spicy food both increase palate fatigue.
2. Recommend one beer for the guest who wants a single beer for the whole meal and defend the choice.
Read the worked answer
Recommend the saison. It has enough carbonation and dry finish for oysters, enough bitterness and carbonation for fried chicken, a malt backbone for lamb, and yeast spice that can bridge chocolate without overpowering it. It is lower in alcohol than the IPA, doppelbock, and stout, so it works across four courses. The Berliner weisse is safer with oysters but too thin for lamb and chocolate. The doppelbock is strong with oysters and too sweet for the tart. The IPA is too bitter for the tart and may clash with the lamb's mint. The imperial stout is too heavy for oysters and chicken. Offer the guest a small taste of saison first and a Berliner backup if they prefer acid.
3. Handle the pescatarian and the bitter-averse guest without redesigning the menu.
Read the worked answer
Pescatarian: keep oysters with Berliner weisse, then ask the kitchen to apply the gochujang glaze to a fish or vegetable plate for the chicken course; pair that with saison or Berliner. The lamb course needs a substitute protein or a substantial mushroom/bean dish; pair it with doppelbock if the kitchen can match the Maillard intensity, otherwise saison. Bitter-averse guest: avoid the West Coast IPA. Use saison for the chicken, doppelbock for the lamb, and a small pour of imperial stout for the tart; Berliner weisse is the safest backup for oysters and dessert if they dislike roast bitterness. Put these substitutions on the service sheet so servers do not improvise at the table.