The Settlement Check and the Fee Dispute
A personal-injury lawyer represented a plaintiff under a written contingency agreement providing for a 33.3% fee plus 'reasonable costs.' The case settles for $120,000. The insurer sends one check payable to the client and the law firm. The lawyer deposits the check into the firm's operating account because, he says, 'it is easier to disburse from there.' The client disputes $9,400 in 'administrative costs' that were not itemized in the agreement and demands a full accounting. The lawyer responds that he will hold the entire $120,000 until the client signs a release and agrees to the fee, adding, 'the money is my security.' A hospital has asserted an $18,000 lien, and the client's health insurer has asserted a $6,500 reimbursement claim. The lawyer has not notified either lienholder or provided a written accounting.
1. Identify the fee and client-property violations.
Read the worked answer
The lawyer violated Rule 1.15 and Rule 1.5. Settlement funds belonging to the client or third persons must be held in a trust account, separate from the lawyer's own funds; depositing the entire $120,000 into the operating account commingles client money with firm money and creates a conversion risk. The lawyer must promptly notify the client and lienholders of receipt, provide a written accounting, and deliver the client's undisputed funds. A fee dispute does not justify holding the entire settlement as 'security'; the lawyer may hold only the disputed portion in trust while the dispute is resolved, and must not use the client's money as leverage to obtain a release or fee agreement. The $9,400 in 'administrative costs' must be tested against the written agreement and Rule 1.5(a) reasonableness; undisclosed or double-charged costs are vulnerable. The hospital and insurer claims require notice and, depending on jurisdiction, protective holds. Failure to account and commingling can support discipline, fee forfeiture, and civil liability.
2. How should the lawyer disburse the settlement now?
Read the worked answer
First, restore the $120,000 to a compliant trust account immediately; do not wait for the dispute to resolve. Prepare a written ledger showing the gross settlement, the contractual fee, itemized costs, and each lien. Notify the client and both lienholders in writing of the receipt and proposed distribution. Pay the client's undisputed share promptly. The 33.3% fee is $39,960; if the fee percentage is undisputed, the lawyer may take that amount only after accounting, but the $9,400 cost figure should be held in trust until itemized and resolved. Hold the $18,000 hospital lien and $6,500 insurer claim in trust pending verification and applicable law; do not pay the client the disputed third-party funds. If the client and lawyer cannot agree on costs, keep the disputed amount in trust and use fee arbitration, a court proceeding, or interpleader. Do not condition the client's undisputed money on a release. Document every transfer and get a signed distribution statement after resolution.
3. The client threatens to file a bar complaint. What are the lawyer's obligations and risks?
Read the worked answer
The lawyer must not retaliate, threaten, or treat the complaint as a reason to hold funds. Rule 8.1 requires cooperation with a disciplinary investigation, and obstruction or false statements can be separate misconduct. The lawyer should preserve the trust account records, fee agreement, time entries, invoices, correspondence, and lien notices; notify the malpractice carrier if required; and consider engaging ethics counsel. The lawyer should also correct the account immediately, because continued commingling after notice aggravates the violation. A bar complaint does not decide the civil fee dispute, but it may trigger review of the fee and client-property handling. The lawyer should not contact the client ex parte if the client is represented, and should not ask the client to withdraw the complaint as a condition of payment. If the lawyer lacks records to prove the costs, the safer course is to refund the disputed amount and resolve the fee issue transparently.