Revenue Recognition on a Layaway-Style Sale
Halbrook Furniture sells a $4,800 dining set to a customer on a "hold" plan on December 20. The customer pays $1,200 down and signs an agreement to pay the remaining $3,600 in six monthly installments. Halbrook retains the right to reclaim the goods if the customer defaults, and the customer may cancel and receive a refund of the down payment minus a restocking fee until the goods are delivered. Halbrook stores the furniture in its warehouse and will deliver it only after the final payment. The company's fiscal year ends December 31. The controller must decide whether to recognize any revenue this year, and the sales manager argues that "cash is coming in, so book the whole $4,800 now." Halbrook has historically collected about 95% of similar hold-plan balances.
1. Should Halbrook recognize the $4,800 as revenue on December 20? Apply the revenue recognition criteria and identify which conditions are and are not met.
Read the worked answer
Revenue should not be recognized in full on December 20. Under accrual revenue recognition, revenue is recognized when the performance obligation is satisfied - i.e., when control of the goods transfers to the buyer.
Applying the criteria:
- Persuasive evidence of an arrangement - yes, a signed agreement exists.
- Delivery / transfer of control - no. The furniture remains in Halbrook's warehouse; the customer cannot use it, and cancellation with refund is still possible. Control has not passed.
- Fixed or determinable price - arguably yes ($4,800), but contingent on completion.
- Collectibility - reasonably assured (95% historical), but this alone does not permit recognition.
The decisive failure is transfer of control. The $1,200 received is a deposit/liability (unearned revenue or customer deposit), not revenue. The sales manager's cash-basis reasoning is incorrect under accrual accounting.
2. What is the correct December 31 accounting treatment, and how does the answer change if the customer takes delivery on December 20 but pays over time?
Read the worked answer
If goods are NOT delivered by year-end (base case):
- Record the $1,200 as Cash $1,200 / Customer Deposits (a current liability) $1,200.
- Recognize $0 revenue and $0 cost of goods sold this year; the inventory stays on the balance sheet.
- Revenue is recognized when control transfers (on delivery), presumably next year.
If delivery occurs December 20 with installment payments:
- Control has transferred and collectibility is reasonably assured, so Halbrook recognizes the full $4,800 revenue on delivery (and matches the cost of goods sold), with the unpaid $3,600 recorded as Accounts Receivable (or Notes Receivable).
- The right to reclaim goods on default is a protective right and does not, by itself, defer revenue when collection is probable.
Key contrast: the trigger is transfer of control, not the timing of cash. Delivery date, not payment schedule, drives the year-end cut.