The Cocoa Cooperative Summary: Selection Under a Word Limit
In a summary exercise, Form Four students read a 450-word passage about a cocoa farmers' cooperative in the South West Region. The passage states that the cooperative was formed in 2018 with 84 members; that payments for beans are often delayed by three to six weeks; that the farmgate price is lower than the price offered by private buyers; that feeder roads become impassable in the rainy season; and that a monthly membership fee of 2,000 CFA francs discourages some farmers. It also mentions that the president's opening speech lasted 25 minutes and that the meeting began at 10 a.m. in Buea. Students must write a summary of the main points in no more than 80 words. One student writes 140 words, begins with the president's speech, repeats 'farmers are suffering' three times, and includes the 2,000-franc fee but omits delayed payments and poor roads.
1. Select the three most important main points for the summary and justify leaving out the president's speech and the meeting time.
Read the worked answer
The three strongest main points are: payments for cocoa beans are delayed by three to six weeks; the cooperative's farmgate price is lower than what private buyers offer; and feeder roads become impassable in the rainy season. These affect farmers' income and the cooperative's viability. The 2,000-franc monthly fee is a secondary point: it discourages some farmers but is not as central as delayed payment, price, and transport. The president's 25-minute speech and the 10 a.m. start in Buea are meeting details, not ideas about the cooperative's problems. A summary must select the writer's main ideas, not reproduce the occasion. Including the speech would use words without covering a main point, and the 80-word limit would force out something important.
2. Write a model summary of no more than 80 words covering the main points.
Read the worked answer
The cocoa farmers' cooperative faces three main problems. Payments for beans are often delayed by three to six weeks. The farmgate price is lower than the price offered by private buyers. In the rainy season, feeder roads become impassable, making transport difficult. A monthly membership fee of 2,000 CFA francs also discourages some farmers. This is about 60 words. It uses the writer's own words, keeps the key figures that carry meaning, and drops the opening ceremony, the speech length, and the meeting time. It also avoids the student's repeated phrase farmers are suffering, which expresses attitude rather than information. The summary is neutral and covers the selected main points in a logical order.
3. Explain why repetition and examples are unsuitable in a summary.
Read the worked answer
Summary is judged on economy and coverage. Repeating farmers are suffering three times uses words without adding a new main point; it expresses attitude, not information. Examples, such as the president's speech, illustrate but do not state the central problem. In an 80-word limit, every word must carry a main idea. Repetition also signals that the writer has not distinguished main ideas from feelings. The student's 140 words exceed the limit and still omit delayed payments and poor roads, which shows the problem is selection, not shortage of words. A summary should be a compressed, neutral restatement in the writer's own words.